• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
East Anglia Bylines
  • HOME
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Health
    • Welfare
    • World
    Cycling.

    Thirty for 30 – how to reduce your carbon footprint

    Oven ready social care plan

    AgeUK and ‘People at the heart of care’

    The UK Youth Parliament

    Should sixteen- and seventeen-year-olds be given the vote?

    Shopping for bargains.

    Savvy tips for cutting your food bill

    Templefields House

    ‘Big Bits of Ash Falling from the Sky’: What happens when your home is on an industrial estate and a warehouse fire breaks out?

    Urkrainian refugees at Warsaw Station

    The Homes for Ukraine scheme: really not “world-beating”

    Pirogov-emergency-team

    Norfolk help for the casualties of war

    A group of international students

    After Brexit: another lost opportunity for young people

    Dentist at work

    Emergency! Dental treatment in lockdown

    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

    Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

    Houses of Parliament

    Democracy and lack of accountability

    Cambridge Europe Day Fete

    Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

    Three Steampunks

    Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

    Smiling Baby

    Twenty years: a staggering difference in life chances

    Shopping for bargains.

    Savvy tips for cutting your food bill

    Templefields House

    ‘Big Bits of Ash Falling from the Sky’: What happens when your home is on an industrial estate and a warehouse fire breaks out?

    Urkrainian refugees at Warsaw Station

    The Homes for Ukraine scheme: really not “world-beating”

    River Deben, Woodbridge

    Rivers have rights: national day of protests against sewage dumping

    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • All
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    Sugar beet

    As farmers suffer, is government’s sugar sell-out just to keep Tory donors sweet?

    Preston bus station

    Community wealth building

    Stansted Airport

    Are plans for Stansted Airport signs of a changing world?

    Snape

    The Ore and the Alde: smugglers, a merman and the home of seaside chic

    The Studio, Elstree

    Was dirty Russian money washed in a Herts public lavatory?

    Ukraine border boxes

    Freedom Boxes and Freedom Buses

    Sunak's wife claims to be non-domiciled

    Is the Chancellor’s wife really a non-dom?

    Rishi Sunak budget

    The economic and political consequences of Rishi Sunak’s failure

    Energy producer profits set to increase 40 fold due to energy price increases

    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • All
    • Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
    Duncan Baker

    Council leader appeals to MP to clean up politics for good after claimed death threats

    Norfolk County Hall

    EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

    Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

    Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

    Mr Pecksniff (Social Media)

    Pecksniff’s Diary

    Cambridge Europe Day Fete

    Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

    Three Steampunks

    Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

    Local election results in the East: good news for progressives?

    Smiling Baby

    Twenty years: a staggering difference in life chances

    South Cambridgeshire: will the voters think local or national?

    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Health
    • Welfare
    • World
    Cycling.

    Thirty for 30 – how to reduce your carbon footprint

    Oven ready social care plan

    AgeUK and ‘People at the heart of care’

    The UK Youth Parliament

    Should sixteen- and seventeen-year-olds be given the vote?

    Shopping for bargains.

    Savvy tips for cutting your food bill

    Templefields House

    ‘Big Bits of Ash Falling from the Sky’: What happens when your home is on an industrial estate and a warehouse fire breaks out?

    Urkrainian refugees at Warsaw Station

    The Homes for Ukraine scheme: really not “world-beating”

    Pirogov-emergency-team

    Norfolk help for the casualties of war

    A group of international students

    After Brexit: another lost opportunity for young people

    Dentist at work

    Emergency! Dental treatment in lockdown

    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

    Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

    Houses of Parliament

    Democracy and lack of accountability

    Cambridge Europe Day Fete

    Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

    Three Steampunks

    Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

    Smiling Baby

    Twenty years: a staggering difference in life chances

    Shopping for bargains.

    Savvy tips for cutting your food bill

    Templefields House

    ‘Big Bits of Ash Falling from the Sky’: What happens when your home is on an industrial estate and a warehouse fire breaks out?

    Urkrainian refugees at Warsaw Station

    The Homes for Ukraine scheme: really not “world-beating”

    River Deben, Woodbridge

    Rivers have rights: national day of protests against sewage dumping

    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • All
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    Sugar beet

    As farmers suffer, is government’s sugar sell-out just to keep Tory donors sweet?

    Preston bus station

    Community wealth building

    Stansted Airport

    Are plans for Stansted Airport signs of a changing world?

    Snape

    The Ore and the Alde: smugglers, a merman and the home of seaside chic

    The Studio, Elstree

    Was dirty Russian money washed in a Herts public lavatory?

    Ukraine border boxes

    Freedom Boxes and Freedom Buses

    Sunak's wife claims to be non-domiciled

    Is the Chancellor’s wife really a non-dom?

    Rishi Sunak budget

    The economic and political consequences of Rishi Sunak’s failure

    Energy producer profits set to increase 40 fold due to energy price increases

    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • All
    • Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
    Duncan Baker

    Council leader appeals to MP to clean up politics for good after claimed death threats

    Norfolk County Hall

    EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

    Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

    Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

    Mr Pecksniff (Social Media)

    Pecksniff’s Diary

    Cambridge Europe Day Fete

    Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

    Three Steampunks

    Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

    Local election results in the East: good news for progressives?

    Smiling Baby

    Twenty years: a staggering difference in life chances

    South Cambridgeshire: will the voters think local or national?

    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
No Result
View All Result
East Anglia Bylines
No Result
View All Result

Book review: This Sovereign Isle by Robert Tombs

Robert Tombs is unconvincing in his sovereignty argument on why the UK had to leave the EU in his book This Sovereign Isle.

Richard CardenbyRichard Carden
July 20, 2021
in Culture, UK
Cover picture of the book this Sovereign Isle by Robert Tombs

Book cover: This Sovereign Isle by Robert Tombs

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

This Sovereign Isle (Robert Tombs, 2021)

Robert Tombs is an expert on the history of France, his wife Isabelle is French, and the two of them together, some 15 years ago, produced a book about the French and the English called That Sweet Enemy. It is massively long but wonderfully good reading. Particularly fascinating is that in just a few places – over the Napoleonic Wars for example – the unity of authorship breaks down and we get several pages of ‘she thinks, he thinks’. The French and the English outlook cannot be reconciled.

Tombs new book on Brexit – This Sovereign Isle – is slim by comparison, though rigorously argued. It begins with a brisk summary of British history since pre-Roman times. Tombs concludes that there is no pattern to Britain’s relationship with the continent, other than an absence of pattern; no settled link, a shifting series of alliances with one continental country after another.

This might be a platform for arguing that Brexit is of a piece with our earlier history. Tombs disclaims that thought – yet the weight of history is a theme running through the book. The EU (for which he has few good words to say) is ‘flying in the face of Europe’s history and its vaunted values’, and Britain, in leaving it, is acting consistently with past behaviour and continuing a centuries-old stand for democracy.

Brexit: Tombs’ conversion

Tombs tells us that after years of being a passive supporter of the EU (in common with most Cambridge dons) he was converted, by some rather chance remarks, into voting Leave at the 2016 referendum. He has the zeal of a convert, and impatience with the views of his former self to match.

We’ll pass briskly over his analytical account of Britain’s fumbling attempts to join in the 1960s and painful efforts to become a fully functioning member of the club through the 1970s into the 80s. The story is familiar. I paused only on one point which may surprise. It surprised me. Tombs says that in concluding (as we did) in the 1960s that we needed to join the EC for economic reasons, we were misreading the data. In fact, he asserts, the UK economy was at that stage (but not in the 70s) performing at least as strongly as the German or the French – which we were thinking we should hitch our wagon to. I have not seen that argued elsewhere. Has Tombs been consulting the right economists?

Weaknesses of the EU

Of more interest for us as we adjust to the done deed of Brexit is what Tombs finds wrong with the EU of today. This is a key part of his mind-set. He tore apart a book by the Financial Times’s Philip Stephens (Britain Alone), coincidentally published on the same day as This Sovereign Isle, in an excoriating review, inter alia for giving no attention to the weaknesses of the EU. In his book those (I summarise) are: disregard for the views of the voters, flaccid economic performance, fatally flawed single currency system which multiplies inequalities, hopeless disunity in foreign affairs, and spanning all this the incessant quarrels between members.

That’s quite a catalogue of weaknesses. He says: it makes a clinching case for leaving. I would say: the quarrelsomeness of the nations of Europe makes a good case for having some system of rules, to keep the lid on the quarrels and limit the damage. It flies in the face of history, yes, but that was precisely the purpose of the project.

Brexit regains sovereignty

Tombs argues that the net benefit to the UK of membership, if any, has been slight, more so than for any other joiner. This is a sound point. Both economically and politically nearly all others gained to a recognisable extent that has weighed with their voters. Germany gained rehab, France a revival of status; Greece, Spain and Portugal put dictatorship behind them and gained cash for modernising their economies; the ex-communist central Europeans similarly.

Britain alone got a poor deal financially at the start, and was not in need of a brotherly embrace from any neighbours. For Britain alone the profit and loss account has all along been more finely-balanced than for our partners; on Tombs’s analysis more adverse for us than was thought at the time. He wants his readers to be in no doubt that we are leaving a sinking ship. He thinks the consequences of leaving will be no great shock, pointing out that not being in the Euro has made leaving feasible for us whereas for any Euro member it would be economically seismic.

Sovereignty or solitude?

Sovereignty is our big prize. Sovereignty (viz. the book’s title) trumps all other arguments for leaving. Sovereignty, he argues, belongs at the level where the people can vote to change their rulers; at the level of the nation state, not the EU. Not for him the argument that we have been pooling our sovereignty in many ways, through international organisations of one kind and another, in exchange for which we draw benefits in security or prosperity.

Sovereignty is only real if it can be exerted. Inside the EU we had simply surrendered it, he says. Others say: although we ‘shared’ our sovereignty on a broader front in the EU than in NATO or the WTO for example, we stood to benefit across a broad range too. As in a marriage. Sovereignty in Tombs’ sense looks like solitude.

As to influence in the wider world, Tombs gives that consideration short shrift throughout This Sovereign Isle. Philip Stephens (op. cit.) lays bare how British prime ministers since the 1950s have been serially deluded about Britain’s weight in the world. Tombs gives us no guidance on what is to come next. Looking to the future he offers only doubts and vagueness: America is still of core importance for us; the English-speaking countries have ‘important shared memories’; ‘the Commonwealth provides soft power based on affection’; ‘leaving the EU demands fresh engagement with the 21st century’. This is fluffy stuff. We are taking a leap in the dark.

Praise is thin on the ground in the book but a few words of commendation are bestowed on the French for superior statecraft; on the énarques who form the upper crust of France’s politicians and civil servants. They are praised for consistency of purpose (in contrast to the Brits), for holding course over the past 75 years or so, pursuing French interests under the guise of European interests.

The thought is left in the air that the victory which Britain’s leaving the field represents for their policy may be short-lived. They may have scored over Britain only to fall prey to Germany. There is no end to history.

Previous Post

Does your vote count?

Next Post

Post-Brexit Britain Fumbles Exports of Plastic Waste

Richard Carden

Richard Carden

Richard is a retired senior civil servant who has worked at top level in the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries, the Department of Trade and Industry and the European Commission.

Related Posts

Lee Anderson MP
Activism

Jack Monroe threatens to sue MP

byStuart Burrell
May 14, 2022
Cambridge Europe Day Fete
Cambridgeshire

Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

byEast Anglia Bylines
May 13, 2022
Three Steampunks
Anglia

Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

byStephen McNair
May 11, 2022
Oven ready social care plan
UK

AgeUK and ‘People at the heart of care’

byAidan Baker
May 9, 2022
Boris Johnson and his cabinet.
Party politics

Our government is killing democracy by a thousand cuts

byRussell Jackson
May 3, 2022
Next Post
Plastic waste mountain

Post-Brexit Britain Fumbles Exports of Plastic Waste

Want to support us?

Can you help East Anglia Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

DONATE

Sign up to our newsletter

If you would like to receive the East Anglia Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

NEWSLETTER

LATEST

Duncan Baker

Council leader appeals to MP to clean up politics for good after claimed death threats

May 17, 2022
Norfolk County Hall

EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

May 17, 2022
Climate change is going global

Climate change now: acting for ourselves and our children

May 16, 2022
Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

May 15, 2022

MOST READ

Norfolk County Hall

EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

May 17, 2022
Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

May 15, 2022
Lee Anderson MP

Jack Monroe threatens to sue MP

May 14, 2022
Mr Pecksniff (Social Media)

Pecksniff’s Diary

May 14, 2022

Tags

Activism Brexit Business Cambridgeshire Climate Community Culture Democracy Development Devolution Economics Education Employment Environment Essex Farming Finance Health Humour Hymns International Women's Day Justice Letters Local elections 2022 Local government NHS Norfolk Opinion Pandemic Partygate Party politics Pecksniff Poetry Politics Poverty Property Rivers of East Anglia Science Sewage Sizewell Social care Suffolk Ukraine VAWG Welfare
East Anglia Bylines

East Anglia Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in East Anglia and beyond.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About us
    • Contact us
    • Bylines Network
    • Complaints
    • Newsletter
    • Privacy Policy
    • Donate
    • Pecksniff’s Diary
  • UK
  • Anglia
  • About us
  • UK
  • Anglia

© 2022 East Anglia Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk

© 2022 East Anglia Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In