Next year, Rachel Reeves is likely to be Chancellor of the Exchequer, so her recent Mais lecture at City University is important. The lecture is one of the major events of the economic calendar, used by past Chancellors, Prime Ministers and major figures to signal changes in economic thinking. What media coverage it received tended to focus on some very specific policy details, and her rejection of borrowing to fund public services. But the speech was most significant for the underlying argument, that Labour will reverse the orthodoxy which has ruled since the 1980s.
History – three phases of government
Reeves identifies three historic phases of economic policy. The first, in the decades before the Thatcher/Lawson revolution, when all parties broadly supported a strong (and often large) state, and an economic policy focused on full employment.
Nigel Lawson reversed this in 1984. Shrinking the state and removing regulation would leave space for the private sector to grow, and the government’s aim should be controlling inflation, not reducing unemployment. That produced massive social disruption and inequality, and a deep recession.
In the third phase, New Labour inherited a recovering economy and a benign global context, which led to sustained economic growth, rising incomes and strong public services. It allowed a concentration of wealth, but it also made it possible to use some of that to ease pressures on the poor. However, weak regulation of the financial sector, and globalisation, increased inequality.
In 2008, this period of global economic and political stability, when the USA dominated global politics and economics, came to an abrupt end. But it has taken some time for all the effects to be felt.
‘Securonomics’
Now, she argues, we need another radical change, different from, but as transformative as, the Lawson one. Global instability has become the norm, driven by three factors: a new turbulent and unpredictable geopolitics, rapid technological change, and climate change.
We can no longer rely on a benevolent global environment: “globalisation is dead”. What people now need from government is, above all, security. Hence, her clumsily named policy of ‘securonomics’. It is no longer enough for the state to get out of the way: we need an active and supportive state, though not necessarily a bigger one.
She argues that the good society depends on growth, and growth happens when people and firms feel confident to take risks. We need firms and people to invest for the long term. But the constant policy and personnel changes of the last decade have created fear and paralysis. It has created a low quality, low skill, and low income economy, and increasing political instability. We are all poorer, individually and in the public services we receive.
Stable institutions
Her plan has three pillars: institutions, investment and reform. Firstly, Labour would strengthen and refocus the institutions of the state, and guarantee their long-term stability. The Bank of England will remain independent, but with a remit which focuses more strongly on climate. The Office of Budget Responsibility will be strengthened. To prevent the Chancellor creating uncertainty, there will be only one annual budget, and that budget will not only consider income and expenditure, but also the stock of public assets.
Stimulating investment
There will be a focus on stimulating investment, with government in close partnership with the private sector. She is abandoning the orthodoxy – dominant since the 1980s – that economic growth only happens when the private sector is given maximum freedom. The state will invest selectively and strategically, guided by new independent institutions: a British Infrastructure Council, an Industrial Strategy Council, and Great British Energy. There will be a Green Prosperity Plan, and a National Wealth Fund. There will be a review of how our huge pension funds are invested, with a view to increasing their economic contribution.
Reform
The third pillar, reform, will include a major overhaul of the planning system, to speed up development, including a programme of New Towns, and mandatory housing targets. A new organisation, Skills England, will oversee skills policy, with a Growth & Skills Levy, and responsibility for skills training devolved to localities. To enable individuals to make the maximum contribution and to progress in work, legislation will strengthen the rights of workers and trades unions. There will be better recognition of the ‘everyday economy’ – that host of small-scale local activities which are central to the life of all communities, and especially to women’s work. There will also be an injection of resources to begin to restore public services.
Alternatives?
The speech will disappoint many, who hoped for a more determined break with the past.
But she would reverse many aspects of current government economic policy. She offers a much more active state, a much closer partnership with the private sector, underpinned by stronger and more independent institutions, and greater security for workers.
There are other paths she could have chosen. She has not proposed the radical redistribution of wealth that some on the left advocate. Nor has she adopted the Modern Monetary Theory endorsed by some radical economists, which would have involved large scale state borrowing. To reassure voters, she has chosen not to abandon the (arbitrary) fiscal rules laid down by the present government. Whatever their merits, these would probably have alarmed the electorate, and jeopardised Labour’s electoral chances.
Her vision is a more limited, but still radical, response to the fundamentally changed, and much more uncertain, policy environment. Like Theresa May, her aim is a ‘strong and stable’ economy, but she probably has a better chance of achieving it. But a lot hangs on the belief that government policy can unlock a lot of unused resources – of people and capital.
Labour is said to be planning for ten years in government. If they could restore a sense of stability and security for citizens and businesses, perhaps they might achieve it.
The full text of Rachel Reeves’ lecture can be found here.











