Over the last few months, we have seen the UK government talk about the £22 billion “black hole” left in their finances by the previous administration. This was followed by the removal of the winter fuel allowance for pensioners not on Pension Credit, and now there are plans for a benefits cut for people with disabilities.
While all this has been filtering into our inboxes, the floundering of the UK’s “Special Relationship” with the US and a potentially weakened NATO has forced the government to look for money to significantly increase our defence spending at a time when the Magic Money Tree is lacking fruit.
Wealth tax debates on the rise
We now see parts of social media where a few “patriotic millionaires” and the occasional MP are promoting a nebulous idea about a “wealth tax”. But they are doing it without laying out a skeleton of how it might work. This lack of detail only feeds its adversaries’ old argument that a wealth tax would be too difficult to administer and would not raise enough revenue.
So, here you have a writer who is a bit frustrated by this situation, and is not an accountant, tax consultant, HMRC employee or economist, but decided to read hundreds of pages of existing research papers (some contradicting each other), to attempt a précis of some options in Q&A bullet points. Please note that the research papers try to make objective opinions based on facts, as assessed by learned academics and professionals, but they are still just opinions.
What is included in wealth?
It is easy to take an over-simplistic view and imagine this in terms of cash deposits in banks, but, in reality, only a tiny proportion is in cash. According to the Knight Frank 2023 Wealth Report, looking at the top 1% of individuals (known as ‘ultra high net worth’):
- 32% is in the value of primary and secondary homes
- 26% in equities (stocks, shares, etc)
- 21% in directly owned commercial property, and
- 17% in bonds (loans to government, corporations, etc)
Who owns the wealth?
- The top 20% own 63% of the UK wealth (Fairness Foundation)
- The UK’s top 1% wealthiest households each have wealth exceeding a value of £3.6 million (ONS 2018-20)
Who wants a wealth tax?
- Many, but Keith Burgon, MP has been one of the most recently active on social media
- Patriotic Millionaires UK
- Around 68% of citizens across 17 G20 countries surveyed back a wealth tax
- Tax Justice UK
- The Wealth Tax Commission Report offers support for a one-off tax to assist with specific emergencies
- (among others)
What kind of tax are they proposing?
Polling by Fairness Foundation found that 74% of respondents support a 2% flat rate tax on wealth exceeding £10 million, but there appears to be no widely consistent opinion as to whether the tax should be one-off or regularly recurring (e.g. annually). The Wealth Tax Commission (Report Section 6.2) recommends an annual tax should only be introduced after reforming existing wealth-based taxes, notably Council Tax and Capital Gains Tax.
What European countries have wealth taxes?
Wealth taxes come in a variety of forms but broadly, Norway, Spain, Portugal and Switzerland are the only countries which still have a wealth tax across a wide set of asset classes. Spain’s is, to a certain extent, progressive according to banded levels of wealth.
France abolished its net wealth tax in 2018 and replaced it that year with a real estate wealth tax. Other examples of the limited application of wealth tax in Europe can be found in the Tax Foundation Europe’s paper “Wealth Taxes in Europe, 2024”.
Why are taxes on residential property wealth favoured over other wealth?
Primarily, it is the ease of collection, mainly by local authorities, who apply part of the income to local expenditure (social services, waste collection, etc), and part to central government (example: Norway). It is also not as quick for those trying to avoid tax to liquidate/switch property assets as it is for assets such as equities and bonds.
What are the limitations to this approach in the UK?
The limitation is mainly in providing a fair valuation. Current council taxes are based on 1991 property valuations. This means that current levels of tax bear little relationship to current house prices.
What are additional considerations for a tax on residential property?
The government might wish to allow deferred payment by those who would have to sell their asset to raise the tax. For example, someone may well have just bought and furnished their £10 million house, but not have a spare £200k to pay tax at 2%. In fact, there are many instances where wealth is tied up in assets which cannot be instantly converted to cash.
If the wealth tax is recurring (e.g. annually), the government would have to decide what total proportion of the value of the property could be taken over a prolonged period. So, a 2% tax over 20 years, assuming a constant valuation, would take 40% of the value of the property.
Determining the degree to which wealth tax would be paid over a prolonged period might be claimed as a credit against inheritance tax. So, if you paid 2% a year for 20 years, a consideration might be to what extent you might be exempted from 40% inheritance tax. For a recurring tax, a fair lifetime cap on wealth tax would have to be determined relative to the total value of assets.
A few opinions…
Any plan for wide-ranging wealth taxes is only as good as the tax avoidance holes through which revenue can escape. The UK government would have to re-think its stance on this. Both UK Capital Gains Tax and Inheritance Tax cover all asset classes, so, with the currently increasing level of financial surveillance and monitoring, increased AI and intelligent algorithms, the collection of taxes across the spectrum of wealth asset classes could potentially become less and less administratively burdensome.
Of course, all this comes with a caveat: there should be no disincentive to invest in UK Government bonds and securities and in UK-based companies. So wealth tax exemptions must be carefully considered.











