What makes wealthy people so wealthy? It is because the UK tax system provides them with the opportunity to accumulate wealth in a way that is denied to most people. The basic problem is simply stated. Some people receive income from paid work, others from wealth (investments, rents, rising value of houses and other assets). Because the latter is much less heavily taxed, wealth accumulates over time. As a result, the richest 10% own 60% of all the wealth in the UK, and their share is growing.
There are five ways in which the taxation of wealth is more generous than the taxation of income.
National insurance
Perhaps the biggest and most pernicious of these injustices in the tax system, is in national insurance. National insurance is paid by everybody who earns an income from work, from age 18 to state pension age. The effective overall rate of national insurance for most people, combining employer and employee contributions, is around 21%.
But there is no equivalent charge on investment income. So, investment income does not contribute towards the national insurance base of the UK. We could stop this. Until 1985 we had an Investment Income Surcharge, was paid at 15% on income from investment sources above a set limit.
Individual Savings Account (ISAs)
ISAs have now existed for 25 years, so although you can ‘only’ invest £20,000 a year, with accumulating interest, some people now have more than £1m in such accounts.
If the income and gains which are earned via ISAs were taxed like income, it would increase the government’s revenue by around £10 billion a year. So, we are subsidising the wealthy very directly.
Capital Gains Tax
First, there are low rates of capital gains tax. Labour is increasing the rates, but they are still much lower than the rate paid by people who receive equivalent income from going to work.
Why should they pay less tax if they get it from a capital gain, rent, interest or whatever, than if they get it from work? There is no inherent moral justice in this bias.
Investment income
Secondly, the tax reliefs available for investment income are extraordinarily generous. Most people can get £1,000 in income from investments before they pay any tax. To earn that at, say, 4%, means you have £25,000 invested: far more than most people own. Why should we have additional tax relief if we get income from investments as opposed to income from work?
Rents
We have low effective tax rates on income arising from rents. Because landlords get a tax credit to set against the cost of buy to let mortgage repayments, the effective tax rate on those properties is low. Although there have been changes in recent years, there is still a bias in favour of the landlord, compared to the person who pays for their own home out of their own income derived from work.
The wealthy don’t live on their income
Finally, remember that the wealthy do not need to live on their income. They can get through the month, pay all the bills and still have something left over. In other words, they’ve got spare money, that they can put into companies, which are taxed at lower rates than the basic rate of income tax. So, the wealthy can shelter their income from tax in the UK corporation tax system.
The proposal for a wealth tax, from the Patriotic Millionaires lobby group illustrates this. Their proposal for a 2% tax on wealth over £10 million is supported by a clear majority of millionaires. That means that someone with £12 million would pay £40,000 a year (2% of £2 million). But at the same time, the interest on the £12 million at, say, 4% would amount to £480,00. So, after tax, they would be £440,000 better off. After 5 years, they would have paid £86,000 in tax, but their wealth would have grown from £12 million to over £14 million.
That’s not all. The next article, published this afternoon, will look at how tax relief benefits the wealthy.
>>>Read Part 2<<<
These articles are based on a blog by Professor Richard Murphy, who has been writing on tax issues for many years.
The original text, and other material on these issues, can be found here.











