Pension saving is not just about how much money you put aside, but also about what that money is used to fund. If your pension fund is investing in things like oil, ultra-processed foods and properties liable to flooding, they are going to be worthless when you want your money back. Far too few people understand that – and this is the real pension crisis we face.
Who should worry about pensions?
People worry about their private pensions, but very few really understand just what a pension is. They think it’s a pile of money they put aside to call on in their old age. And in a very limited sense, that is true. You can save money in a pension scheme and hope to live on it in your old age. But it takes many preconditions to make that possible. And if they collectively fail, you won’t have a pension at all. And it’s those preconditions I’m really worried about.

The people who are most likely to be interested in pensions are those who have reached the point where they might want a pension. But the generations who should be most worried are the ones that are following. And this is because the deal in pensions is that one generation will create enough capital investment during their lives, for the next generation to also be able to give up some of their income to pay the pensions of that older generation in retirement. It is this bargain about the creation and use of capital which transfers value between generations, which is the real core of the pension arrangement.
And it is this core which is, I think, widely misunderstood.
It’s not money, it’s assets
Your pension can only provide you with security in old age if you can sell off the assets you have saved in. And the people who can buy them are the next generation. If they decide that those assets are worthless, then, frankly, all your savings will come to nothing, because you can’t live off your state pension alone. So, unless the savings people make, which have a monetary form, are invested in assets which are actually of real use to future generations, then frankly, as a pension savings mechanism, they’re utterly useless.
Many assets may prove worthless
The vast majority of the money now saved through pension funds in things like stocks and shares, are actually in assets which will be of remarkably little value to generations to come.
For example: oil fields will not be worth much in 30 years’ time. Although we know that we should not burn the oil we’ve already discovered, pension companies are still investing in the likes of BP and Shell, who are spending vast sums to discover yet more oil resources. If they burn them, we will die. Since the climate cannot sustain the burning of these resources, the next generation really do not need that activity because it is deeply detrimental to their well-being.

The same is true of saving in property, when so much of it is at risk because of, for example, the failure to defend it from floods. At a recent conference, bankers admitted that 80% of the properties they own in places like the City of London are likely to be unusable in the future, because they will be flooded, unless we take major steps to prevent more water reaching central London. This, they said, was a simple statement of fact. But none were worried, because they all believed they could sell their property portfolios before this flooding would take place, which was utterly naive, because everybody, of course, holds the same belief, and therefore the market will at some point collapse.
In other words, we are seeing vast amounts of money being invested in ‘stranded assets’, valued on the assumption that everything stays the same into the future. But we know it won’t. And, therefore, much of this pension saving is useless to coming generations, however much money they might have put into a pension fund.
We should be investing in the future
So, what we must understand is that if pensions are to remain relevant, they need to be represented in terms of the underlying assets of use to the next generation, and the one after. Those are the people you will rely on in your old age.
So we need pension oversight from the government which takes these factors into account, and requires pension funds to invest in assets which are of value for the future. It requires them to move out of sectors with a high likelihood of stranded assets, and instead move resources into those areas which we most definitely need: sustainability, sustainable energy, sustainable housing, and defences against floods.
That’s what the pension contract requires but is not what our government is doing. Nor is it what our pension funds are doing, all of whom are living in cloud cuckoo land.
If we really are to understand pensions, we need to understand that they must be used for the sake of funding investment for change. Until we do this, your pension fund is frankly worth nothing more than the paper it is written on because it may not provide for you in old age. And that, to someone like me, is a matter of serious concern.
More from East Anglia Bylines












