The interim report, Young people and work, led by the former Labour Minister, Alan Milburn, is a sobering read for all of us. The few pages of the Review section are enough to give any reader the key statistics and overall sense of why so many young people are “out of work and out of sight”.
In my experience as someone who has spent a working life of 42 years in education as a teacher, headteacher and latterly as a consultant supporting trainee teachers and staff in schools, it is one of precious few government publications that has been based substantially on feedback from young people. The comments from over 400 young people are heart-wrenching at times. They build a picture of what the report calls a “failure of a system stuck in the past”, where the range of organisations from education, health, welfare and employers are failing to meet the needs of the current young generation.
This is not a new problem, but it has become more complex. In 2007, I was a headteacher in a rural Suffolk High School serving a community with plenty of disadvantage, from a lack of transport infrastructure, a limited employer base, highly seasonal employment based on tourism, geographical isolation from investment, and decision-makers and a population with low educational attainment and low incomes.
Putting ideas into practice
My vision was to confront some of the disadvantages by trying to bring employers closer to the school, to ensure work experience was a meaningful and universal experience for all students in the 14-19 phase. This would also require widening the curriculum beyond just GCSE and A-level to incorporate vocational options that responded to real-world employment sectors.
I employed a full-time Employment Engagement Officer who helped us create a solid base of employers who were willing to interview all students in Year 10, and offer quality work experience for a week. This developed into longer work placements for a range of students, some of whom were struggling with the standard GCSE/post 16 routes and had accompanying behavioural and mental health issues.

At the same time, we had been part of a fantastic partnership of like-minded high schools and an FE college which led to the building of a rural skills centre funded by a grant of £3.5m from the EU (remember them?). Several hundred students between the ages of 14 and 18 attended courses over the years in sectors such as construction, engineering, health and beauty, and hospitality and catering.
They and their parents were very positive about this opportunity and the value being placed on work-related learning which frequently led to job offers with local employers. The number of NEET young people in England was close to the EU average at the time, and the morale of young people in the education system in our community was positive in the main.
Change of government – change of direction
In 2010, the advent of the new coalition government led to the removal of the funding that supported many of these developments; careers education was scaled back to a minimum offer and work experience became an optional element. Very soon the curriculum was focused upon knowledge and facts, a narrow set of traditional academic subjects (the EBAC or English Baccalaureate), and the importance of examination grades rather than outcomes for young people. The Wolf Report of 2011 generated a bonfire of vocational qualifications and a focus on what ministers at the time called the “Gold Standard” of English education – A-levels.
And today
In 2026, the world for young people is a very different place. The Milburn report picks out the barriers to the 84% of young people, deemed NEET (not in employment, education or training) who are looking for meaningful employment and training. The barriers span mental health, an overly narrow educational curriculum based on exam grades rather than outcomes leading to employment, a lack of contact with employers, issues linked to lack of support for students with Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND), the impact of the global pandemic and for graduates, a heap of debt and a dearth of first-time jobs. There are nearly one million young people who are NEET, and this will rise steadily to 1.6m without a complete reform of health, education, welfare and employment sectors.
A case for optimism
So, where might a more positive world for our young people emerge from? Interestingly, Alan Milburn flags up the experience of The Netherlands where the percentage of NEET young people stands at 4.1% (cf UK 13.7%). The Netherlands has built a system of transition to employment and training over several decades. Contrast this with our experience of five-year parliaments and the stop-start policy changes which undermine any long-term strategy.
70% of students in The Netherlands follow a vocational pathway (MBO) which consists of work-based learning and apprenticeships in a country which sees technical education as valuable and the foundation of a successful economy. The government gives employers a premium subsidy of nearly £6,000 per student to take on young people on 32-hour contracts. Local councils offer tailor-made engagement programmes, with mental health support included, and the flexibility for young people to change routes and programmes so that there is no “dead end”. This is a system with cohesion between the different bodies supporting the young person, and investment to match.
The report’s key recommendations
The most important thing is what Milburn recommends to government as the way forward: that the final report leads to long-term action not words; that the action is bold and comprehensive enough to meet the scale of the challenge facing young people; and that it builds hope, through people, strategies and investment, to make a difference.
More from East Anglia Bylines

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.










