Autumn approaches and with it the annual advent of machinery cutting our hedgerows. For some this act is controversial. Is the flailing doing more to kill the hedgerows than promote their growth? Will the trimmed branches denude the hedgerow of fruits and ivy flowers that are future food sources for birds, insects and mammals? Should the work be delayed until mid-winter?
The management of trees and the role of the qualified tree surgeon is widely recognised. However, the same is not true for hedgerow management. While there is guidance and some online courses are available, all too often those undertaking the trimming are driven by the need to avoid complaints from locals rather than understanding what is best for the hedge.
Old and new hedgerows
A hedge will always try to revert into a line of trees. Many of the oldest hedges were formed as woodland was cleared, and the green that was left became a hedgerow boundary. Over the past century, many hedgerows have disappeared with an estimated 118,000 miles of them lost since 1950, due largely to intensification of agriculture. The consequences in terms of soil erosion, loss of wildlife habitat and the importance of the hedge as a windbreak are now recognised.

Recently, there have been countrywide schemes run by councils and the Woodland Trust – some with the support of businesses – to replant hedgerows. Around East Anglia volunteers, landowners and farmers have laboured to plant miles of saplings and hedging whips. And it is a common sight to see row upon row of plastic or cardboard protectors guarding a newly planted hedge. It can take years for hedgerow saplings to mature and in their early years they can be a very tasty morsel for deer. But unless the understanding of how to manage a hedgerow improves, the prospects for the thousands of recently planted saplings is bleak.
Plainly there are many landowners and farmers who know how to grow and maintain a thick, healthy hedgerow. It is a joy to pass these and hear the bird song of its inhabitants or see the fluttering of butterflies and bees. But there are far too many hedgerows flailed to within an inch of their lives by blunt mechanical instruments, cutting far too deeply into the main tree stem, weakening – or worse, gradually killing – the plant.
The skill of hedgerow management
Hedges go through a life cycle. Nigel Adams, award-winning vice chair of the National Hedgelaying Society, defined a ten point scale to illustrate this.

Hedgerows will respond well to sensible and rotational pruning. But repeat cutting to the same height is often done for neatness or for safety reasons along roadsides. While a hedge may not appear to suffer immediately, over time and with repeated cutting at the same level, the remaining stems become larger and often gnarled and twisted. This indicates that the hedge is being stressed. It will slowly weaken and die. Good hedge management recognises this and the good hedge manager knows to intervene only when appropriate.
What about the controversy that cutting hedgerows in autumn deprives wildlife of essential food?
The farmer’s view
“Most farmers take a lot of pride in their hedges,” says Graham Denny, a Suffolk farmer with a passion for birds, especially rearing turtle doves. He advocates the cutting on alternate sides of a hedgerow and top, one in three years. “This maintains the essential berry harvest and habitat for overwintering insects that are essential for many birds and mammals – wrens, long tail tits, goldcrest, shrews etc.
“Managing hedgerows before winter is better for all kinds of wildlife, especially if you are playing percentages,” Denny adds. “Any cutting in autumn is on dry soil. This is by far the best time to run on margins. The warm weather sees insects active and mammals’ burrows firm enough to take the weight of several tonnes of cutting machinery. It also allows time for vegetation to recover before winter, giving dry homes above ground essential for insects.”
Denny goes on to explain that cutting hedgerows in midwinter after the busy harvest and winter sowing period is harmful. The weight of the heavy machinery on the soft wet ground risks killing dormant insects and small rodents in the tussocks and grass margins. Such loss is significant as these creatures and insects are essential food needed to feed nesting birds and chicks in the coming year.
Planting hedgerows is very labour-intensive and can be a cold, back-breaking job. It can take many days to plant a long hedgerow. For the sake of the survival of ancient hedgerows, for those already stressed from poor past management and for newly planted hedges, it’s critical that farmers and landowners employ trained workers who understand how and when to prune.
And most importantly, to know when to leave well alone.








