At last year’s Munich security conference, US Vice President, J.D.Vance, made a dramatic attack on Europe. He claimed that the continent is in civilisational decline, facing an erosion of democratic norms through censorship, suppression of dissent and exclusion of populist voices. And he presented European constraints on hate speech, political extremism, terrorism and pornography as part of a culture war.
The issue was elaborated in the 2025/2026 US National Security Strategy (NSS) which claimed that Europe faces a “civilisational threat”, driven by mass migration, declining birthrates and cultural loss. To counter this, the NSS commits the US to work actively to defend “traditional, Christian-based, sovereign-nation values”, and to promote “patriotic”, right-wing, and anti-globalist movements within Europe to combat this “erasure”.
Some see this, not as a rolling back of so called ‘wokeism’, but a declaration of war on long-held European values. If an ally is turning into an enemy, we should be on the lookout for their agents here at home.
Let freedom reign?
The latest step in the US government strategy is the creation of a new online portal, ‘freedom.gov’, to actively counter European and UK legal constraints on internet access. It has long been a US tactic to support democratic groups in repressive regimes. But it seems they are now turning on European democracies.
The EU and UK have both been creating legislation to protect citizens, and especially children. Personal data and official secrets are protected, and there are restrictions on hate speech, illegal and harmful content and terrorism.
All these laws command wide public support, though there will be disagreement about some of the details. But they have been determinedly opposed by the tech giants of Silicon Valley, and now by the US government itself.
What our laws protect
We have long ignored some fundamental differences between US and Europe, and especially in relation to free speech. In the US, the First Amendment of the Constitution gives legal primacy to the protection of free speech of all kinds. Europe, with very different traditions, sometimes prioritises the protection of citizens and the state. We do this through a network of laws, some of which may be targets for this US initiative. In most cases, it is an offence for a UK citizen to evade these laws by acting in another country, if the result is visible in the UK.
The UK’s Data Protection Act bans the unauthorised disclosure of personal data, except in the case of genuine public interest. This includes disclosing it to anyone outside the UK, and the law can be applied in the UK courts. Some offences under the Act are criminal and can incur prison sentences. Others are civil matters, with offenders liable for damages.
The Online Safety Act imposes a duty on online platforms and search engines to remove illegal and harmful content. Again, this includes services based outside the UK, if they have UK users. Platforms must take “proportionate measures” to block illegal content, reduce the risk that their service is used to commit or facilitate offences, and put in place reporting, complaints and user‑empowerment features. Offending organisations can be fined up to £18mn or 10% of their global earnings, and managers can face imprisonment.
There are other laws restricting what can be published. Material related to terrorism is covered by terrorism legislation, and offences can carry lengthy prison sentences. Contempt of court by publication can carry a prison sentence up to two years, and an unlimited fine. The penalties for obscene publication can be up to five years imprisonment. Unauthorised disclosure under the Official Secrets Act incurs a penalty of up to two years.
Who are the informants?
This initiative by the US government is a test of how far our government is able to protect its citizens. And the same is true across Europe.
However, there is a further issue: where is the material to come from? In some cases, it seems this new American service will merely publicise something already in the public domain. Indeed, some of the initial information on this project cites publishing parliamentary speeches, which are always published online within a day.
But if the material is not already in the public domain, somebody is finding it in this country, and passing it on to the freedom.gov service. In most cases, this will breach one or more of the laws listed above, in which case the supplier of the information can be prosecuted or sued.
It may be that this initiative is a back of the envelope project, with no real planning. Not all the bold initiatives announced by this US government ever see the light of day. But the Munich speech and the Security Strategy suggest that it is more than this.
If there is a serious plan, they presumably think they have a network of informants (or ‘spies’ as we might once have called them) in place. Given the overt support for the present US regime by Reform UK, one might speculate about who these informants might be.
For people – who claim to be nationalists – to be actively colluding with a foreign power to undermine the safety of our citizens seems, to put it mildly, ‘strange’.
More from East Anglia Bylines

Bylines Network Gazette is out!
The latest Bylines Network Gazette is out now. Become a Friend of Bylines Network or upgrade to a paid Substack subscription, and you will get access to a vital collection of citizen articles and stories.
Journalism by the people, for the people.











