• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
East Anglia Bylines
  • HOME
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Health
    • Welfare
    • World
    Cycling.

    Thirty for 30 – how to reduce your carbon footprint

    Oven ready social care plan

    AgeUK and ‘People at the heart of care’

    The UK Youth Parliament

    Should sixteen- and seventeen-year-olds be given the vote?

    Shopping for bargains.

    Savvy tips for cutting your food bill

    Templefields House

    ‘Big Bits of Ash Falling from the Sky’: What happens when your home is on an industrial estate and a warehouse fire breaks out?

    Urkrainian refugees at Warsaw Station

    The Homes for Ukraine scheme: really not “world-beating”

    Pirogov-emergency-team

    Norfolk help for the casualties of war

    A group of international students

    After Brexit: another lost opportunity for young people

    Dentist at work

    Emergency! Dental treatment in lockdown

    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

    Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

    Houses of Parliament

    Democracy and lack of accountability

    Cambridge Europe Day Fete

    Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

    Three Steampunks

    Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

    Smiling Baby

    Twenty years: a staggering difference in life chances

    Shopping for bargains.

    Savvy tips for cutting your food bill

    Templefields House

    ‘Big Bits of Ash Falling from the Sky’: What happens when your home is on an industrial estate and a warehouse fire breaks out?

    Urkrainian refugees at Warsaw Station

    The Homes for Ukraine scheme: really not “world-beating”

    River Deben, Woodbridge

    Rivers have rights: national day of protests against sewage dumping

    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • All
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    Sugar beet

    As farmers suffer, is government’s sugar sell-out just to keep Tory donors sweet?

    Preston bus station

    Community wealth building

    Stansted Airport

    Are plans for Stansted Airport signs of a changing world?

    Snape

    The Ore and the Alde: smugglers, a merman and the home of seaside chic

    The Studio, Elstree

    Was dirty Russian money washed in a Herts public lavatory?

    Ukraine border boxes

    Freedom Boxes and Freedom Buses

    Sunak's wife claims to be non-domiciled

    Is the Chancellor’s wife really a non-dom?

    Rishi Sunak budget

    The economic and political consequences of Rishi Sunak’s failure

    Energy producer profits set to increase 40 fold due to energy price increases

    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • All
    • Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
    Duncan Baker

    Council leader appeals to MP to clean up politics for good after claimed death threats

    Norfolk County Hall

    EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

    Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

    Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

    Mr Pecksniff (Social Media)

    Pecksniff’s Diary

    Cambridge Europe Day Fete

    Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

    Three Steampunks

    Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

    Local election results in the East: good news for progressives?

    Smiling Baby

    Twenty years: a staggering difference in life chances

    South Cambridgeshire: will the voters think local or national?

    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Health
    • Welfare
    • World
    Cycling.

    Thirty for 30 – how to reduce your carbon footprint

    Oven ready social care plan

    AgeUK and ‘People at the heart of care’

    The UK Youth Parliament

    Should sixteen- and seventeen-year-olds be given the vote?

    Shopping for bargains.

    Savvy tips for cutting your food bill

    Templefields House

    ‘Big Bits of Ash Falling from the Sky’: What happens when your home is on an industrial estate and a warehouse fire breaks out?

    Urkrainian refugees at Warsaw Station

    The Homes for Ukraine scheme: really not “world-beating”

    Pirogov-emergency-team

    Norfolk help for the casualties of war

    A group of international students

    After Brexit: another lost opportunity for young people

    Dentist at work

    Emergency! Dental treatment in lockdown

    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

    Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

    Houses of Parliament

    Democracy and lack of accountability

    Cambridge Europe Day Fete

    Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

    Three Steampunks

    Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

    Smiling Baby

    Twenty years: a staggering difference in life chances

    Shopping for bargains.

    Savvy tips for cutting your food bill

    Templefields House

    ‘Big Bits of Ash Falling from the Sky’: What happens when your home is on an industrial estate and a warehouse fire breaks out?

    Urkrainian refugees at Warsaw Station

    The Homes for Ukraine scheme: really not “world-beating”

    River Deben, Woodbridge

    Rivers have rights: national day of protests against sewage dumping

    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • All
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    Sugar beet

    As farmers suffer, is government’s sugar sell-out just to keep Tory donors sweet?

    Preston bus station

    Community wealth building

    Stansted Airport

    Are plans for Stansted Airport signs of a changing world?

    Snape

    The Ore and the Alde: smugglers, a merman and the home of seaside chic

    The Studio, Elstree

    Was dirty Russian money washed in a Herts public lavatory?

    Ukraine border boxes

    Freedom Boxes and Freedom Buses

    Sunak's wife claims to be non-domiciled

    Is the Chancellor’s wife really a non-dom?

    Rishi Sunak budget

    The economic and political consequences of Rishi Sunak’s failure

    Energy producer profits set to increase 40 fold due to energy price increases

    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • All
    • Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
    Duncan Baker

    Council leader appeals to MP to clean up politics for good after claimed death threats

    Norfolk County Hall

    EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

    Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

    Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

    Mr Pecksniff (Social Media)

    Pecksniff’s Diary

    Cambridge Europe Day Fete

    Europe Day fête in Cambridge on 14 May

    Three Steampunks

    Imagining other worlds: steampunk in East Anglia

    Local election results in the East: good news for progressives?

    Smiling Baby

    Twenty years: a staggering difference in life chances

    South Cambridgeshire: will the voters think local or national?

    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
No Result
View All Result
East Anglia Bylines
No Result
View All Result

Farage returns to the fray: net zero is the new Brexit

Will net zero become the cause that unites the divided Conservative Party, and revives the career of Nigel Farage?

Stephen McNairbyStephen McNair
March 6, 2022
in Climate, Party politics, Politics
A divided Tory party

A divided Tory party. Photo by World Economic Forum via Flickr (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0)

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Two months ago we suggested that opposition to net zero might be the cause which binds the fracturing Conservative Party together, as its internal divisions become more obvious to voters. We suggested that it was a topic which could revive the deep social and political divisions which the Brexit referendum had exposed. Once again a symbolic issue would enable a faction on the political right to both feed on and promote a populist suspicion of elites and of government intervention. With energy prices already set to rise by 50% in April, and the war in Ukraine driving them still higher, it will not be difficult to revive the sense of victimhood that drove the Brexit vote.

It is no coincidence that the Parliamentary opposition to net zero is focused around the Net Zero Scrutiny Group, led by Steve Baker, a leading figure in the leavers’ European Research Group. Now the central figure of the Leave campaign, and the ultimate opportunist, Nigel Farage, has seen the opportunity.

Nigel Farage Climate Article
Mail on Sunday

Support for Net Zero is wide but shallow

Most UK politicians now see net zero as broadly common sense, just as they saw EU membership a decade ago. The Johnson government, and all the opposition parties, agree on the general goal, and even on much of the strategy, if not the pace. In a quiet way a majority of people probably think it matters. But below the surface, there are divisions which could be revived to rescue a struggling Conservative Party. Net zero could be the tool which saves them, just as Brexit did a few years ago.

There has always been a body of climate change deniers, but the “sceptical” energy lobbies have broadly accepted the net zero ambition and are seeking to develop greener strategies. In Britain, climate scepticism is largely limited to a marginal group of eccentrics, who can be ignored, or fobbed off by tweaks to policy measures.

The public generally respond positively to the idea of net zero, but that support is not deep. At the time of COP26 in October, when IpsosMORI carried out a poll on the issue, they found widespread support for the idea. But support fell rapidly when they were asked about specific steps to achieve it. People may be in favour in principle, but most have not seriously considered the implications for their own lives. As energy prices soar, much of that support is likely to melt away.

This can revive the tribes

Net zero has the potential to divide political tribes in much the same way that Brexit did. The referendum vote was never wholly about the European Union. For leavers, it was about a sense of exclusion from decision making, of grievance and neglect. Much of the same anger can be focused around net zero, and specifically energy prices. We saw this in action in France with the “yellow vest” protest movement, which began with anger about fuel prices, and spread rapidly on a much broader front. By contrast, the people who believe in net zero, and the need to take radical measures to achieve it, have much in common with the Brexit remainers. Once again, they can easily be caricatured as an elite, out of touch with “ordinary people”, and cushioned by relative prosperity against severe price rises.

Brexit held the Conservative party together. It is the one thing which binds MPs with wildly different political views. On one hand we have the newly elected MPs from the “red wall” seats, who seek stronger government intervention, and if necessary higher taxes, to restore their communities. On the other hand there is the old guard, who seek a small state and low taxes. Opposition to net zero could take the place of Brexit in holding that coalition together.

The risks of complacency

One great mistake of the remain campaign was complacency. Its supporters assumed that the case for remaining was self-evident, and that everyone recognised, and received, the benefits of membership. So it was not necessary to make a strong case.

Since most people didn’t care much about the EU, making a strong case would merely provoke the opposition. There was some reason for this. Before the referendum was called, polling showed that most people took little interest in the EU and knew little about it. However, the very fact that most people took little interest in the EU, enabled the leave campaign to hitch a whole raft of grievances to it. Those grievances mattered more to most people than the EU itself.

There is a danger that history repeats itself. We must not assume that people will accept the case for net zero, either in principle, or in the specific policies required. We cannot go ahead without consent, and no party (except perhaps the Greens) has seriously tried to map out the costs and benefits. The lesson of Brexit is that, without consent and a degree of understanding, a groundswell will find a way of expressing itself.

Arming against the threat

Supporters of net zero need to have good answers to some real questions. Why are we doing this?

There is an abstract historical argument, that since Britain started the drive towards carbon intensive industry in the 19th century, and our recent prosperity was built on that, we have a responsibility to help put things right. But that will cut little ice with opponents.

Our current impact on global heating is marginal. True, our share of global carbon output is higher per head than most countries of the world, but it is still only 1.1 percent of the whole. Why not wait until the US, India and China take serious steps forward?

What are we actually proposing, in concrete terms? Some policy options involve much more sacrifice than others. What are the choices, what technologies and strategies do we advocate, and how will those impact individuals?

A positive agenda

To win this fight, net zero has to be a positive decision. On Brexit, faced with a choice between a status quo, which many people did not much like, and a radical break, people chose the latter. It would be very easy to present net zero as a cost – higher fuel prices, colder homes, less travel, more limited diet.

People must want to make these changes because it will make life better for us all in the foreseeable future, not in three generations’ time. It must especially improve conditions for those who have benefited least from the last decades of economic change.

Over Brexit, we failed to engage people and communities who felt excluded from policymaking by a metropolitan elite. We risk making the same mistake over net zero.

But that is not inevitable. As Tracy Brabin, the Mayor of South Yorkshire, argued in a recent Fabian pamphlet, there is real scope for green industries in the places which used to drive the old energy technologies of coal and steel. Our coastal communities, with their links to offshore oil and gas, have potential in offshore wind, and perhaps carbon storage. But for this, we need an industrial strategy. The Labour party has plans for one, but the Conservatives are culturally hostile to such ideas.

Two key messages

There are two conclusions. Firstly, this issue has the power to restore the unity of the fracturing Conservative party in the same way as Brexit did. In doing so, it could consolidate, and even deepen, the cultural divide which Brexit opened, with such damaging results for our politics and all of us. The alleged harm that membership of the EU inflicted on us was always vague, and often focused on trivia. Energy price rises hit everyone, on top of rising inflation (some of it caused by Brexit itself).

Secondly, we must not assume that those who generally like David Attenborough will support net zero when they see their energy bills rising, and punitive taxes on motoring. There is an argument to be won.

Many of our readers will believe that the case is self-evident, but we need to convince a lot of other people. We didn’t do it last time. Let’s not make the same mistake again.


More from East Anglia Bylines

Boris Johnson's Tories are in disarray
Opinion

What happens to the Tories now?

byRichard Murphy
January 16, 2022
Tags: Party politics
Previous Post

Can exploited women and girls be helped today?

Next Post

Raising student fees – again!

Stephen McNair

Stephen McNair

Stephen McNair is retired and lives in Norfolk, where he is active in progressive politics. He spent most of his career working on education policy, especially adult education, at national and international level. He founded the Centre for Research into the Older Workforce, and chaired a European Scientific Research Committee on Demographic Change. Stephen is a member of the EAB editorial team.

Related Posts

Duncan Baker
Local government

Council leader appeals to MP to clean up politics for good after claimed death threats

byPeter Thurlow
May 17, 2022
Norfolk County Hall
Democracy

EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

byPeter Thurlow
May 17, 2022
Climate change is going global
Activism

Climate change now: acting for ourselves and our children

byJocelynne Scutt
May 16, 2022
Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk
Anglia

Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

byAnna Damski
May 15, 2022
Mr Pecksniff (Social Media)
Anglia

Pecksniff’s Diary

byEast Anglia Bylines
May 14, 2022
Next Post
studetnt loan app

Raising student fees – again!

Want to support us?

Can you help East Anglia Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

DONATE

Sign up to our newsletter

If you would like to receive the East Anglia Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

NEWSLETTER

LATEST

Duncan Baker

Council leader appeals to MP to clean up politics for good after claimed death threats

May 17, 2022
Norfolk County Hall

EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

May 17, 2022
Climate change is going global

Climate change now: acting for ourselves and our children

May 16, 2022
Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

May 15, 2022

MOST READ

Norfolk County Hall

EXCLUSIVE: shocking coup by Norfolk’s Tories

May 17, 2022
Pylons at Aldringham, Suffolk

Shock as National Grid proposes 180km of new pylons across East Anglia

May 15, 2022
Duncan Baker

Council leader appeals to MP to clean up politics for good after claimed death threats

May 17, 2022
Lee Anderson MP

Jack Monroe threatens to sue MP

May 14, 2022

Tags

Activism Brexit Business Cambridgeshire Climate Community Culture Democracy Development Devolution Economics Education Employment Environment Essex Farming Finance Health Humour Hymns International Women's Day Justice Letters Local elections 2022 Local government NHS Norfolk Opinion Pandemic Partygate Party politics Pecksniff Poetry Politics Poverty Property Rivers of East Anglia Science Sewage Sizewell Social care Suffolk Ukraine VAWG Welfare
East Anglia Bylines

East Anglia Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in East Anglia and beyond.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About us
    • Contact us
    • Bylines Network
    • Complaints
    • Newsletter
    • Privacy Policy
    • Donate
    • Pecksniff’s Diary
  • UK
  • Anglia
  • About us
  • UK
  • Anglia

© 2022 East Anglia Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk

© 2022 East Anglia Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In