Dear Editor,
With regard to the article The great heat pump paradox: more heat, less progress, while a great deal has been written about the economics of heat pumps from the point of view of the consumer, it is worth adding some perspective from the point of view of an installer, by comparison with a registered gas installer.
First, I’m afraid, a minor quibble. You state in the article that “By contrast, gas and oil boilers are technically simple”. This is not really the case. They are an established technology, but they are an extremely dangerous technology if not correctly installed and maintained. I don’t imagine that you have any other piece of technology in your house for which you have a separate alarm specifically to warn you when it goes wrong and tries to kill you. For this reason, the RGI and Gas Safe qualifications are quite technical and difficult to obtain.
However, the economics of heat pumps from the point of view of the installer or engineer do not work out as well because (a) there is a far smaller installed base and (b) they do not require the same mandatory annual checks and frequent maintenance as a gas or oil boiler. This means that most of the money for the heat pump engineer comes from installing new units, whereas for an RGI/Gas Safe engineer the bulk of their income will come from servicing and maintenance.
Both will be looking at installing between two and four new units a month, but the gas engineer will probably service 200–400 units per annum. You can see that, as things currently stand, it does not make sense for an RGI/Gas Safe engineer to get into the heat pump business.
You can contrast this with what happened in the Netherlands, where the government subsidised additional training for all of its gas technicians in air-to-air heat pumps – what we know in the UK as F-gas certification – and also significantly subsidised installations of these units without requiring the removal of any existing gas or oil boiler, allowing them to act as additional rather than complete replacement heating.
This built up a skilled workforce and a large installed base of the new technology, and reduced actual gas demand because, for most of the year, an air-to-air heat pump can provide most of the heat requirements of a Dutch household.
I hope this helps explain some of the slow uptake of heat pumps in the UK. There is also more to say about the UK preference for air-to-water over air-to-air, but that is a different topic.
Duncan Jones
Caistor, Lincs
More from East Anglia Bylines

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.







