Thomas Tallis’s motet for 40 voices, Spem in Alium, has almost mythical status among singers. It’s glorious to hear, and exciting (nerve-racking?) to sing. There will be a relatively rare opportunity to hear a live performance in Ely Cathedral this Thursday.
Who was Thomas Tallis?

Good question. Relatively little is known about him. He was probably born in the early part of the 16th century, probably in Kent. Later in life, he was a member of the Chapel Royal, the private chapel staff – clergy and choir – that followed the monarch around the country. Tallis may have been a boy singer with the Chapel Royal and/or at Canterbury cathedral. He is first recorded as employed at Dover Priory for £2/year as organist in 1531.
Henry VIII’s dissolution of monasteries and priories started in the late 1530s. Tallis left Dover and went to be organist first in Billingsgate, then at Waltham Abbey in Essex, which in 1540 was the last monastery to be dissolved. Little of the original structure survives.
Tallis moved to Canterbury Cathedral, and then a couple of years later began his adult employment in the Chapel Royal, as a composer for Henry VIII, Edward VI, Mary I and Elizabeth I, and as an organist from 1570. He was a member of Queen Elizabeth’s household until 1585, the year of his death.
Thomas Tallis the musician

Tallis would have received excellent musical training. The Chapel Royal choir was required by the monarch to sing the appointed music for every Sunday and festival, as well as for festivities and special occasions. They went with Henry VIII, for example, to meet Francis I of France at the Field of the Cloth of Gold. The young Tallis would have learned an extensive repertoire in a variety of styles.
Tallis’s anthem If ye love me is arguably the earliest surviving post-Reformation anthem. It sets words from the gospel reading for Whit Sunday, also called the Day of Pentecost, which in 1549 was the first day on which Edward VI’s new Book of Common Prayer was used by the Church of England. The style is spare, and the words are set homophonically (as in most church hymns) in the accessible style favoured by the religious reformers.
In both sacred and secular music, the 16th century was the heyday of vocal polyphony. Music was generally commissioned by a wealthy person – it was a status symbol to have your own musicians performing to order. Secular music, such as madrigals for small singing ensembles, were the juke-box of the time.

A challenge from Italy
In 1567 a visitor arrived in London from Italy. Alessandro Striggio, an employee of the Medici, was one of those who had been experimenting with the acoustic possibilities offered by St Mark’s Cathedral in Venice, where a large body of instruments or musicians could be placed in small groups in various lofts around the cathedral.
Striggio had packed a status symbol in his trunk: a mass for 40 voices divided into five choirs of eight voices. Thomas Wateridge, writing in 1611, reports that on hearing it an unnamed duke asked “whether none of our English men could sett as good a songe” – and Tallis took up the challenge. The duke who had set the challenge, when he heard Spem in alium performed, reportedly thought it so much better than Striggio’s composition that he took the gold chain from his neck and gave it to Tallis.
Spem in Alium

Spem is very different from Striggio’s mass. It too uses 40 voices, but arranged in eight choirs of five voices. The piece is shorter, using tightly constructed polyphony. The choirs sing in groups of two or four, but at key moments of drama all eight choirs sing in homophony. It may first have been performed at Nonsuch Palace, where the octagonal banqueting hall with its four first-floor balconies would have lent itself perfectly to staging the eight choirs in an arrangement reminiscent of St Mark’s in Venice.
In an informative and entertaining lecture Jaakko Mäntyjärvi wonders whether the motet was written for Elizabeth’s 40th birthday in 1573. He shows that Tallis encoded his name using a simple number code (T = 19 etc.) to make his name add up to 69. The piece is 138 (= 2 x 69) bars long and uses 40 voices. The first time all voices sing together is in bar 40. The next time is in bar 69, at the exact half-way point. The next time, on the key word “Respice”, is at bar 109 (= 40 + 69). Coincidence?
A plot?
Tallis, like his pupil and colleague William Byrd, was almost certainly a “recusant’, a lifelong Catholic, but Tallis was a bit more circumspect.
His choice of text for Spem, however, is intriguing. It is inspired by chapter 9 of the Book of Judith, and refers to an episode in which the Assyrians, under Holofernes, are attacking the home city of Judith in Israel. Breaking out of the besieged city, she makes to seduce Holofernes, who becomes drunk so that she is able to behead him, thus defeating the enemy.
Throughout Elizabeth’s reign there were various plots to remove her from her throne by Catholics who considered her an illegitimate imposter. Mäntyjärvi suggests that Tallis may well have been aware of the 1571 Ridolfi plot. Were Judith’s words – an appeal to God to approve the good reason for her violent deed – intended as a cleansing ritual for the plotters before carrying out the plot? They never did, as they were exposed and the Duke of Norfolk was executed. If Mäntyjärvi is right, the public performance of the motet would have been a daring act of bravado.
This Tudor gem lives on
We may not know exactly when or why Tallis composed Spem in alium, but it has become a much-loved jewel in the choral repertoire. King’s School in Canterbury made a remarkable recording during lockdown, perfectly engineered from tracks recorded individually by students singing at home. It gives a clear visual sense of the fluctuating numbers of voices involved. A more traditional performance, albeit with more than one voice per part, is a live performance conducted by early music expert Harry Christophers. You may catch sight of some singers counting furiously as they wait for the right moment to start singing!
One of the piece’s more surprising outings was to be featured in Fifty Shades of Grey where, the comments on YouTube suggest, it gained some new fans. Is this a plot twist?
More about choral music from East Anglia Bylines

CLICK HERE TO DONATE TO OUR CROWDFUNDER
HELP US BECOME STRONGER SO THAT WE CAN CONTINUE TO DELIVER POWERFUL CITIZEN JOURNALISM!








