The Brexit leave campaign promised to free Britain from EU laws and regulations. The claim was that “Europe” had imposed these on us (even though, as members of the EU, we had played a full part in writing them). So, the Conservative government has been keen to “take back control”. It is now clear who will gain this newfound control. And it is not British voters.
The government’s plans are, in effect, a massive transfer of power to ministers, who will have the right to make and unmake laws, without any scrutiny by Parliament, let alone the electorate. They also risk laws simply vanishing without anyone noticing until a case comes to court. The result is unlikely to be good for the country, or for democracy.
Over 40 years of legislation
During the UK’s 47 years as a member of the EU and EEC, a host of laws and regulations were agreed at European level, and passed into UK law.

In June, the government said there were 2,400 of these. They involve 300 policy areas, and 21 sectors of the economy. The largest (570) were in the field of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, but 16 government departments were affected in total. Issues include the Working Time Regulations, fisheries, food, water and vehicle standards, environmental taxes, health and safety, equal treatment of social security claimants, and highly technical regulations on issues like the control of avian flu.
Abolishing all these on Brexit day would have created legal chaos. To avoid that, the government provided, in the 2018 European Union (Withdrawal) Act, that most EU law existing at that time would continue to apply, as UK “Retained Law”, until we had new laws to replace them.
A new Bill
The plan for replacing those laws has now been presented to Parliament, as the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill. Its stated purpose is: “by ending the special status of retained EU Law, we will reclaim the sovereignty of Parliament, and restore primacy to Acts of Parliament”. This is the taking back of “control of our laws” which we were promised. However, it is doubtful if this is what people thought that phrase meant.
This type of bill is called a “sunset bill”, because its fundamental principle is that all retained EU law will simply disappear at the end of 2023, unless a minister has made an active decision to convert it to UK law. If they decide to do that, it will become “Assimilated Law”, with any specific EU-related aspects (like the right of appeal to the European Court of Justice) removed or replaced.
The government claims that the process of reform is transparent. To help this, they have published an online “Retained EU Law Dashboard” which aims to list all the EU laws which will be affected by the Bill. However, researchers have now identified another 1,400 which are missing from the dashboard.
In truth, nobody knows how many laws and regulations there are, so there will be laws which simply vanish unnoticed until someone brings a case to court. For those who hate the “nanny state” this may look like a step forward. It will not be for the rule of law.
To date there has been relatively little protest, but concern is increasingly being expressed on the left about the implications for employment law.
Power to ministers
Because of the volume and complexity of the laws involved, it is impossible for Parliament to scrutinise every detail. So, the Bill gives ministers the power to decide whether to retain, replace, restate or modify the EU law, or to defer a decision up to 2026. Ministers can rewrite the law to achieve the same purpose, and will have considerable scope to modify it, provided that in doing so they do not increase the regulatory burden. But if the minister does nothing, the law just vanishes.

The dangers are obvious. Normally, to make laws in the UK, the Government proposes a bill. That bill is examined and debated by Parliament. MPs, interested parties, experts and pressure groups and individuals all have a chance to contribute views. This takes time, but improvements are made, legal ambiguities and unintended effects get removed in the course of debate, and the end product is usually better as a result.
In the case of the current Bill, once it passes, none of this will happen. Where a redrafted law or regulation is proposed to replace the old EU one, it will have been prepared by civil servants and approved by the relevant minister. If parliamentary approval is needed, it will be on the basis of a simple yes/no vote. However well intentioned, there are likely to be mistakes, leading to confusion, expensive legal disputes, and perhaps real injustices.
A further risk is that, where ministers choose to diverge from the retained law, they may, deliberately or accidentally, create new conflicts with the EU and new barriers to trade.
More complexity
The situation is made more complex by devolution. On 8 November, the Scottish government made formal objections to the Bill, in both its intentions and timing. It is not clear how far the Scottish and Welsh Governments will be able to make their own decisions. Could, for example, the Scottish Government decide to keep EU laws which England has abandoned? Could they choose to retain a role for the European Court of Justice in interpreting the law, which is clearly not the English intention?
A further complexity is that, for some years, three different sets of law will be in force, since legal cases can take years to resolve. According to when the case began, it could be heard under EU law (where a case began before Brexit day), under “retained law” (for the period 2020-2023), or under the new law for cases beginning after 2023. More scope for uncertainty and legal dispute.
The timetable
The Bill was approved in principle with a Second Reading in the House of Commons in October. The details are now being scrutinised in Committee, which is expected to report back at the end of the month. It will then pass to the House of Lords, where it is likely to meet some strong challenges from experienced lawyers. As Philip Moser KC said, “I would be highly surprised if this passes the Lords unscathed”.
All decisions to change the law must be made by the end of 2023. This means a great deal of work for civil servants, which cannot begin in earnest until the Bill passes into law, since the Bill may be amended by Parliament. But if they don’t make decisions in time, the current laws simply lapse, leaving us with uncertainty about what is and is not lawful.
Some lawyers have expressed concern that, because of the volume of work required, and perhaps to avoid scrutiny, there will be a rush of proposals to Parliament at the end of 2023. As George Peretz KC said:
“Departments might be tempted to turn up to Parliament in December 2023 with whole rafts of replacement revocation … Parliament would have a gun to its head: “unless you get it through, it all falls””.
Conclusion
It is far from clear that there is anything fundamentally wrong with many of these laws and regulations, which we helped to make when we were in the EU. But they are offensive to the small number of people who are ideologically committed to severing all links with the EU, or to reducing law and regulation in principle.
This Bill gives unprecedented power to ministers to make law without serious parliamentary scrutiny. But even with the best of intentions, ministers will make mistakes when working against this very tight timetable. And some laws will almost certainly simply disappear without anyone noticing.
Once again, Brexit is forcing confusion, complexity and costs on our government, when what most people and businesses want is clarity, certainty and predictability.
It is not clear that any of this is what people thought they were voting for in 2016. It is even less clear that we will be better governed as a result.










