The absolute failure to understand the motivations and objectives of Europe when discussing UK-European relations has run through the Brexit process like the words “Great Yarmouth” through its rock. And while the refusal to deal with reality may be as granite solid as the souvenir sweets, it is no longer a sign of anything sweet or great.
A case in point is the Independent’s reporting (among other outlets) of a new position paper. It stated that Prime Minister Andy Burnham had been “handed a plan” to allow Britain to join the European single market “without having to accept controversial terms, such as freedom of movement or having to join the euro”. Furthermore, the single market in question here would apply to goods only, and so the City of London would be immune from things like rules governing the security of the financial system and caps on bankers’ pay. What’s not to like, Mr Burnham?
Except, of course, this proposal comes neither from the European Commission, nor the Council, nor the Parliament, nor even from member states. It is by Nick Boles, a former Tory government minister. European input? Close to zero. Stone the crows!
A British solution to a European question
Two questions present themselves: why propose something that clearly contravenes Europe’s established interests just to protect the May-Johnson red lines established in the Brexit period? And why are we back to “Britons talking to Britons” and thinking that’s adequate?
This proposal is definitely not in Europe’s interests. First, it would reinforce non-member states as central to European defence, when the strategic imperative is to build up a European system – from manufacturing to forces in the field – capable of operating independently. (What ‘European’ means there is open for debate; that it would be centred on the European Union institutions, is not.) It offers nothing of substance above the UK’s current commitments to Nato.
Perhaps more worryingly, Boles and co. utterly fail to absorb the lessons of successive UK governments. To take a non-exhaustive list of examples: the proposal would see Europe putting the rock on which the Union is built – the single market – in a new body – “the European Confederation” – outside of European law. Why would Europe conspire in its own destruction?
It would see the UK exempt from freedom of movement. But no other potential signatory state is interested in this siding: they want free movement as much as they want to be full members of the European family.

And the Boles proposal sets up the kind of differential Great-Yarmouth-rock-shop-pick-n-mix membership that would surely be gravel in the workings of the Union itself.
The pick-and-mix problem
The reason such proposals continue to gain traction is down to a number of misconceptions: primarily an idea that the UK is the equal of Europe and that the two can meet in the middle (this doesn’t happen; they meet where Europe, the far larger mass, is at). More subtly, they rely on undermining Europe’s negotiating advantage of being legally unified by pushing for solutions at the multilateral level (many UK leaders hate that Europe negotiated as one during Brexit, wanting to be able to pick off states or have 28-way negotiations).
Equally, these types of proposals put a lot of store in the decision of Andy Burnham to opt for no free movement, no single market, no customs union, as if that were an equivalent to the foundational treaties of the most successful union of states the world has known. Europe’s momentum is very much towards countries accepting their responsibilities.
Britons talking to Britons
But in truth this problem comes about because of Britons talking to Britons. They decide they’ve reached what they consider to be a fair compromise, and so that’s the position to move forward with.
Like the Malthouse Compromise. Or PM May deciding she’d “opt in” to parts of European law. Or various UK ministers expecting a seat on the European Council. Or mutual recognition (without free movement) as proposed by the likes of Best for Britain. Or the indicative votes. Or “flexible” alternative solutions to the Northern Ireland problem. And even mutual enforcement.
I can’t believe the authors of this paper don’t know any Europeans. So is this perhaps a total disregard for European society and politics as being real? Perhaps it is a defensive reaction to a complex about being the smaller partner, donning the mantle of confidence that the UK position is all that matters? However, this reinforcement of exceptionalism in Westminster, and in the public, is preventing addressing the reality of Brexit.
Try asking Europe
I mean it’s not rocket science. You ask around. Or try a mental exercise and identify with the other side. Ask, as I’ve proposed previously in these pages, how does Europe (really) benefit?
Make that central to every discussion in the UK and there might be quick progress towards a position that is actually negotiable.
More from East Anglia Bylines

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.









