
There are many reasons to be pessimistic about the state of UK politics right now. Labour recently had a knee-jerk reaction to the EU Commission’s suggestion of a youth mobility scheme. They characterised it wrongly as “Free Movement” and, together with their stated preference for individual bilateral deals, certainly brought one of the main issues into stark relief.
So occasionally we should look for the hidden possibilities and optimistic scenarios. Having apparently painted himself into a corner with “red lines” that seem to cut off the most obvious routes to economic improvement (Customs Union and Single Market) is there any way Starmer could be a political Houdini, and with one bound, free himself from his own trap? Well, perhaps.
These are our “givens” for this piece of political “imagineering”.
Navigating Starmer’s ‘red lines‘
The next government is almost certain to be formed by the Labour Party; all the signs point to a large, possibly very large majority.
As far as the Conservative party is concerned, all the signs are that a serious defeat will lead to a bitter struggle within the party between broadly, two competing factions. At some point they will eject the losing Prime Minister and choose a new leader. If they go for a compromise leader, that unfortunate person will spend most of their time trying to keep the two factions together, to maximise their political influence.
More of the same.
No-one will be fooled; we will simply be waiting for the day when one faction ejects the other completely. Perhaps that will come so quickly that a new leader will be installed, and the dissidents will be expelled or walk away.
Right now, there are several candidates on the right of the party vying for the position, and it seems quite probable that that faction will prevail. There is no alternative “moderate” candidate visible who is clearly in command of wide support within the party, though various right-wing candidates will be touted as “compromise” candidates.
So a Labour government will take power, facing what is without question the most challenging set of circumstances since the Attlee government took office at the end of WWII.
Labour’s policy choices amidst challenges
Even with the ‘red lines’, Labour will have positive policy choices that can makes some difference. There can be some further rapprochement with the EU; there can even be limited agreements, broadly under the heading of “dynamic alignment”. This will at least give some certainty to business, though they would give the UK little influence over the direction of travel. Stretched to the limit, the flexibility available might lead to a bespoke “Customs Arrangement”; note, not membership of the Customs Union. I know plenty of people will decry this possibility. It would certainly depend on a degree of goodwill from the EU side which can’t be taken for granted.
There are of course domestic issues the incoming government will have to tackle which they may well see as a higher priority than agreements with the EU. Here they are still hemmed in by their own budgetary and fiscal “red lines”.
I think there is probably more wriggle room in these than seems apparent now. Once you are in government, in charge of the narrative, and able to influence the presentation of the figures, you do have more power than you have in opposition.
Assessing Labour’s long-term strategy
So let’s say the new government makes what can be seen as significant progress towards goals on say, the NHS, or housing, or transport, or water, or any of the myriad problems left behind by the wrecking Tories, that enjoy broad public support. For how long?
How long before the electorate becomes restive at the lack of change and progress? Or to put it the other way round, how long will the new government’s honeymoon last? Impossible to tell, of course, but if the electorate is reminded of the chaos of the previous government by continued infighting in the opposition, or a right-wing leader proclaiming they were never given a chance and should have gone further, faster, the government could enjoy a reasonably long honeymoon.
Mid-term is a traditional potential danger point. Two and a half to three years in may be the government’s “sweet spot”, shortly before it all becomes rather tedious for some of those who helped them into power, or who hoped to go further, faster in a reforming direction.
Keir Starmer has so far done a very good job of persuading the electorate that he is a safe pair of hands. His approach seems to be paying off. But does he really believe that “more of the same” is going to satisfy people for long? Halfway through the first term, with the horrors of the current government still fresh in the mind of the electorate and the Conservative Party still in disarray, if the Labour government has been successful at building trust and confidence in its competence and long-term plan, might be the time to seek a new, more radical reforming mandate.
Labour’s prospects for change
The Fixed-term Parliaments Act is gone, putting a weapon in the hands of a Prime Minister who is prepared to take some risks. A good time to assess whatever progress has been made, to explain to the electorate that the situation is even more difficult than it seemed at first, and that a fresh mandate is needed for a more flexible approach to the political, economic and strategic realities the country faces. A new mandate with more flexibility than in 2024.
Certainly not a mandate which proposes an application to join the EU, but one which builds on whatever progress has been made and seeks to deepen and strengthen the relationship with Europe to mutual advantage.
Closer alignment to European standards across a range of areas; removal of barriers where possible, further strengthening of the strategic relationship and closer political cooperation. A new mandate could of course also encompass more domestic reform, which might well even be the headline. Crucially, no referendums; just a regular vote to provide a new mandate for government, in the traditional British way.
Impossible? No. Likely? No. Somewhere between the two. But if you watch an intelligent person, a lawyer, apparently paint themselves into a corner, you should always allow the possibility they have seen how an exit can be made. There may be others I haven’t thought of. But this one is feasible.
Discuss.







