Every young person in the UK needs financial education and it should be part of the school curriculum. Although there is now a legal requirement that young people have financial education before they leave school, there’s actually nobody checking that they get it. And those schools that do provide it, do it — let’s be honest — pretty perfunctorily. As a result, we have young people coming into the workplace with almost no understanding of money.
What they don’t know
I’m not talking here about money in a macroeconomic sense, I’m simply talking about money in a microeconomic sense, and how it impacts them.
- They don’t know how to run a bank account.
- Most of them can’t work out how to save if they need to, and what the benefits of saving might be.
- They most certainly don’t understand interest rates on savings, and more importantly, nor do they understand interest charges on borrowing.
- They don’t know the difference between a debit card and a credit card.
- They don’t know what tax is.
- They don’t know why they will be taxed or where taxes go to.
- They don’t know why they will also be asked to sign up for a pension scheme and what the consequences might be, especially if they don’t.
- They aren’t prepared for things like credit deals, which they might be asked to sign if they want to buy their first car, or take out a loan to do something else.
- They aren’t prepared for things like renting a home, or, in the longer term, buying one, and all the consequences of such arrangements.
- Nor do they know how to avoid fraud. They’re exposed to risk and are innocent in the face of it.
And all of this is a complete failure to provide a proper education for things that people really do need to know.
How might we provide this education?
We might consider dropping some parts of the curriculum to make time. We might, for example, drop compulsory maths in the way that it is taught now so that we could include budgeting, taxation and accounting; and we might want to talk about how we change some of the civics curriculum to cover other parts of this.
Whatever the case, we need decent teaching materials. Martin Lewis had a go at this a while ago, with a book that seems to have disappeared into thin air. His videos got tiny numbers of views, which is not encouraging. The few resources which exist are not being used.
This is something that has troubled me for some time. Young people are so underprepared for the world around them that they are literally being taken for a ride in almost everything they do — and I hate that idea. I want people to be able to manage the real world in which they live, and money is an essential part of that.
Where will the money come from?
A couple of years or so ago, I noticed that the Institute for Chartered Accountants had picked up well over £100 million in fines from its own members for their failure to undertake proper work on behalf of their audit clients. Every one of those firms had failed in some form of assurance activity.
They had let the public down, and they’d been fined for it. And, instead of using that money, the Institute put it on its balance sheet, and gave discounts to its members against their membership fees. It used none of it for the public good.
I approached the then chief executive of the Institute of Chartered Accountants, and said I wanted that money used for public purpose. “After all,” I said, “you were not meant to be enriched because your members failed. You, too, failed if your members failed; you, too, should be making good for the failures for which you are responsible. And you should be doing that by undertaking education on finance for people in the communities in which they live, and most especially for young people.”
At the time, the fines amounted to nearly £150 million. I suggested that £100m of that should be put into a fund to pay for an education programme for young people in schools. This would include payment to create teaching materials, and for the teachers to deliver these lessons on a peripatetic basis, so that specialists were delivering it, not just ordinary class teachers who were already overloaded.
I thought this was the way in which accountancy could be made to look relevant to society, and accountants could plug themselves in the process, I thought.
I was told no one was interested.
And yet, time and again, I see that they are.
Sign a petition
There is now a petition on the government petition website about this, created by a member of the Youth Parliament. The idea has been covered in Investor’s Chronicle and the Financial Times.
People know that we are missing a trick here. The Institute of Chartered Accountants has the money because it’s sitting on the fines that it got as a result of the failure of its members.
Ethically, I believe it has a duty to act with that money for the public good. But it says legal impediments exist, and my answer is, then change your rulebook — every year they make changes to that rulebook, approved by the Privy Council.
So, any objection that they can’t legally do this is nonsense. They can, they could, they should. And young people are entitled to an education which protects them from the abuse that they might otherwise suffer from the financial services sector in the UK.
Perhaps the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales needs to respond to the question: why it is not participating in protecting people from that abuse when they could?
I would certainly like to know the answer.
This article comes from Richard Murphy’s Funding the Future Blog












