• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9771
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
East Anglia Bylines
Advertisement
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Development
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series
No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Development
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series
No Result
View All Result
East Anglia Bylines
Home Featured

The dilemmas of assisted dying: ‘Truelove’

As Parliament reconsiders its position on assisted dying, we republish our article about how a Channel 4 drama explored some of the issues

Stephen McNair by Stephen McNair
29 April 2024
in Featured, Health
Reading Time: 9 mins read
A A
Woman holds hand of dying friend

Lindsay Duncan in Truelove. Channel 4 by permission

Share on Bluesky

After receiving a diagnosis of terminal cancer, the broadcaster Esther Rantzen has been campaigning to legalise assisted dying in the UK. After more than 200,000 people signed her petition, MPs discussed the issue today (29th April). This was not a decision making debate which could lead to a vote. Rather, it was designed to test how far support has changed since it was last considered in 2015, and whether the issue should be pursued. The debate was informed by the publication of the Health Select Committee’s report on the issue, and the government’s response published today.

The debate was very well attended, with a majority of Members speaking in favour of changing the law, but some passionate speeches against. Summing up the debate, both Conservative and Labour parties confirmed that they will allow time for debate, but since this is a matter of conscience, it would be a free vote, although there was some concern that, on such a complex issue it was inappropriate for this to be decided by a Private Members Bill.

The East of England was well represented, with speeches by Andrew Selous, Rachel Hopkins, Duncan Baker, Matt Hancock, Therese Coffey, and Chloe Smith. All, except Therese Coffey, spoke in favour of Parliament considering changing the law.

Earlier this year we published the following article, which looks at some of the issues, and how they were explored in the ITV drama Truelove.

Truelove: dramatising the dilemmas

Drama can sometimes help us to understand complex political, ethical and cultural issues. Hot on the heels of ITV’s story about the scandal of the Post Office subpostmasters, a new drama from Channel 4 has highlighted another issue – assisted dying – in its serial, Truelove.

Truelove follows the story of a group of old friends, all in their 70s. In the pub after a funeral, they agree that if any member of the group is faced with a terminal illness, they will all help them to die with dignity at a time of their own choosing. All very drunk, they swear, “Truelove”. Predictably, this happens, and one of them asks for the promised help. In the cold light of day, they face the prospect that standing by their promise means breaking the law, and possibly ending their own lives in jail. When a second case arises, we see the dangers of abuse.

Friends swear "Truelove" in Channel 4 series
Swearing ‘Truelove’ in Channel 4 film. Channel 4 by permission

The series shows them facing the dilemmas, and the impact on their personal lives and relationships, uncovering old wounds and tensions from the past. It shows us experienced police and a coroner tacitly choosing to look the other way, while a young ambitious constable defies her superiors to pursue what she suspects (rightly in law) is a crime.

What the group promised was illegal, but many will think it is right: an expression of “true love”. But the issue is not simple, as Truelove demonstrates.

Changing laws round the world

In recent years, attitudes to this issue have been changing. More than 250 million people around the world now have access to some form of assisted dying law. It is legal in eleven US states, in Australia, New Zealand and seven European countries. Legislation is planned in France, and in Germany the Constitutional Court has ruled that a ban on assisted dying is unconstitutional.

In Britain, things move more slowly, and resistance is more powerful, though polls suggest that it is not more widespread. The campaign for change is led by Dignity in Dying, who have made specific proposals for change.

The Isle of Man is leading, and could become the first jurisdiction in the British Isles to legalise assisted dying. In October 2023, a Bill passed its Second Reading there with 70% support, and it is expected to become law in 2025.

In Jersey, after a public consultation, and a citizens’ jury which voted strongly for change, legislation is being drafted for decision later this year. 

In Scotland, a proposed Bill was put to public consultation in 2022, and received 76% support from over 14,000 respondents. That Bill is now before the Parliament.

In Ireland, the Dáil has created a Special Committee on assisted dying, following the publication of a private member’s bill which received strong public and political support.

Changing guidance to the Courts

In the light of Supreme Court rulings in individual cases, the Crown Prosecution Service has revised its guidelines. They now advise that assisting a suicide, a suicide pact or ‘mercy killing’ should be distinguished from murder or manslaughter, if the deceased individual had reached a voluntary, settled and informed decision to end their life, and if the suspect was motivated wholly by compassion. But these guidelines do not change the law – assisted dying in any form remains illegal and still carries the risk of investigation, prosecution and serious jail time.

Assisted dying: a task for Parliament

In the UK itself, the Supreme Court has been asked several times to rule in favour of assisted dying in specific cases. Each time, it has maintained that this must be a matter for Parliament to decide. However, in 2018, after rejecting Noel Conway’s case, three senior supreme court justices acknowledged that the issue was of “transcendent public importance”, and called for Parliament to act.

Unsurprisingly, MPs are reluctant to grasp such a sensitive nettle. Nevertheless, there have been several attempts to introduce legislation. Most recently, in 2021, Baroness Meacher introduced an Assisted Dying Bill in the House of Lords. Despite its wide support, opponents presented a long list of ‘wrecking’ amendments, and the Bill ran out of time.

However, following a Westminster Hall debate, in December 2022, Parliament’s Health and Social Care Select Committee launched its first ever formal inquiry into the issue. It is expected to report later this year. The political parties view this as a matter of conscience, and they will not take party positions. So, if Parliament decides to legislate, it will be by a free vote. When it finally happens, it will certainly be contentious; views are strongly held, and the debate may well become unpleasant. However, Truelove dramatises clearly the painful dilemmas which face well-intentioned people under the current law.

The debate

Campaigners are asking Parliament to rule that, in very specific circumstances, it should be legal to assist someone to die: if they are of sound mind, have a clear terminal diagnosis for conditions like cancer or motor neurone disease, and it is their clear settled wish.

Woman holding the hands of another woman who is asking for help
Asking for help: Image credit: Channel 4. Used with permission

Some people object to change on religious grounds, though it is unclear why that should affect non-believers. Others believe that it is always wrong to kill anyone, and abandoning that principle is the first step on a slippery slope, leading to the killing of inconvenient elderly relatives or disabled people. They argue that palliative care can relieve most of the pain and distress. Truelove also highlights the very real dangers of abuse by relatives or carers, if there is inadequate regulation or supervision.

Supporters of a change in the law argue that it is cruel to force people to choose between solitary suicide, and spending the last months of their lives in pain and distress (for themselves and their loved ones). They claim that it is possible to put proper safeguards in place to prevent abuse, and that palliative care does not always deal with the pain. They argue that an avoidable risk to a few should not outweigh the suffering of many.

The medical professions no longer oppose change

In the past, the medical professions have opposed change, fearing that legalising assisted dying might affect their relationships with patients, and conflict with their codes of professional ethics. However, eight professional bodies have recently switched to a neutral stance, and none now opposes change. As a group very directly affected by any change, the College of General Practitioners has set up a working group to study the implications for their members.

UK Public opinion supports change

In March 2019, Populus polled 5,695 people in the UK on the issue. Overall, 84% supported the proposal advocated by Dignity in Dying, and only 9% opposed. Support was overwhelming among all groups, ages, parties and regions. And there was majority support among all religious groups except Muslims (and even they only opposed change by a narrow margin of 48% to 37%). Christians supported the proposals by 82% to 11%.

It is very clear that there is widespread public support for a change in the law. Truelove’s dramatisation can help people understand some of the issues and recognise the importance of proper safeguards if change is to happen. When the Parliamentary Health and Social Care Select Committee reports later this year, we will see whether MPs, perhaps in a new Parliament, will grasp the nettle.

Truelove is transmitting on Channel 4, and you can watch the whole series on catchup.


More from East Anglia Bylines

Funeral for Arnt Olsen in Norway, 1932. The funeral guests are all gathered around the coffin, children at the front, all very soberly dressed, There are flower wreaths on the coffin.
Featured

Funerals are optional, dying is not

by Robert Ashton
9 December 2023
German radio operator WW2. This is a display in a museum in the Ardennes about the 1945 Battle of the Bulge. It shows a soldier sitting at a desk with a telephone attached to the wall, and a radio on the desk. It has wires coming from it to something in his hands - he is probably transmitting in Morse code.
Cambridgeshire

The Nazi spy at large in Cambridgeshire

by Stuart Burrell
8 November 2026
A home energy adviser points to information on a leaflet while discussing energy-saving measures with a woman in her home.
Lifestyle

Keeping Norwich homes warm: free advice as Britain invests in cleaner energy

by East Anglia Bylines
7 November 2026
Composite portraying political tensions between Andy Burnham and Shabana Mahmood over immigration and Europe, with a chessboard suggesting political strategy and compromise
Opinion

Pecksniff: Immigration – Mahmood, Burnham and the moral question

by East Anglia Bylines
7 November 2026
Farage creeps away. He is tip-toeing away from a signpost that points in 3 different directions: Westminster and Clacton towards the left and, towards the right, 'Away', which is the direction he's going in.
Featured

Farage is a firebrand

by Helen Forte
6 November 2026
Tags: Assisted dyingCrimeGriefLaw
Previous Post

Local elections in the East: the ones to watch

Next Post

Castle Point election: a battle of independents

Stephen McNair

Stephen McNair

Stephen McNair is a member of the EAB editorial team, living in Norfolk. Now retired, he spent most of his career working on education policy, especially learning and work, at local, national and international level. He is Emeritus Professor of Education at the University of Surrey, and previously a Director of the National Institute for Adult Continuing Education. After 'retiring' he spent five years chairing a European research committee on demographic change.

Related Posts

Farage creeps away. He is tip-toeing away from a signpost that points in 3 different directions: Westminster and Clacton towards the left and, towards the right, 'Away', which is the direction he's going in.
Featured

Farage is a firebrand

by Helen Forte
6 November 2026
Woodcut of 3 witches on broomsticks flying with the middle one depicted as a devil heading towards a lady.
Culture

The magic hidden in our homes: six centuries-old ways to ward off evil

by East Anglia Bylines
31 October 2026
Andy Burnham and European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen meet during the UN General Assembly in New York
Brexit

Is Britain ready to join Europe again?

by East Anglia Bylines
21 October 2026
A care worker in a blue uniform takes notes while talking with an older woman sitting up in bed.
Health

Surprising findings: social care is not ‘bad work’

by Andrew Harrop
17 October 2026
Welded steel sculpture of two large open hands, I hold and am held by Rick Kirby, in Woodbridge, Suffolk.
Featured

Who gets to decide which of my parents is real?

by The Hidden Voice
11 October 2026
Next Post
External view of Castle Point Borough Council offices

Castle Point election: a battle of independents

SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

Tags

Activism Brexit Cartoons Christmas Climate Community Conservation Conservatives Democracy Economy Elections Environment EU Farming General Election 2024 Government Health History Housing Labour Letters Local government Net zero NHS Norwich Opinion Our place in Europe Party politics Pecksniff Politics Polling Pollution Poverty Reform UK Renewables Sewage Social care Something for the weekend Tax Trump Ukraine Voting Wealth Wildlife Women
East Anglia Bylines

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in East Anglia and beyond.

East Anglia Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Letters
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2021-2026 East Anglia Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9771

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Development
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series

Newsletter sign up

Crowdfunder

© 2021-2026 East Anglia Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9771