In a groundbreaking speech at Davos, Mark Carney argued that the post‑Cold War “rules-based international order” has ruptured, and that middle powers like Canada must respond with honesty, strategic autonomy and cooperative coalition‑building rather than nostalgia, or passive accommodation. He set out a doctrine of “values‑based realism” in which Canada strengthens its domestic economy and security, diversifies international partnerships, and works with other mid‑sized states to construct a new, more resilient order that matches rhetoric with reality.
The order, a useful fiction
He described the ‘rules-based world order’ as a pleasant “fiction” that is being replaced by unconstrained great‑power geopolitics, where the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must. The old system, underpinned especially by US hegemony, delivered public goods such as secure sea lanes, a stable financial system and dispute‑resolution frameworks. But it always involved hypocrisy: powerful states exempted themselves, trade and law were enforced asymmetrically, and middle powers knowingly colluded in rituals they knew were partly false, because the fiction was useful and safe.
Rupture, weaponised integration and “fortresses”
Over the last two decades, successive crises in finance, health, energy and geopolitics have exposed the risks of extreme global integration and eroded faith in multilateral bodies such as the WTO, UN and COP. Economic interdependence has become a weapon for the powerful: tariffs are used as leverage, financial infrastructure as coercion, and supply chains as points of vulnerability. It is no longer possible to pretending that integration is mutually benign: it actually produces subordination.
In response, many states are seeking strategic autonomy in energy, food, critical minerals, finance and supply chains. This is a rational move for survival but one that can lead to a world of national “fortresses” that is poorer, more fragile and less sustainable.
The ‘Carney doctrine’: values‑based realism
So, for middle powers, the choice is how, not whether, to adapt: either by simply raising walls or by pursuing a more ambitious path of collective resilience and principled pragmatism. He has chosen the latter, describing Canada’s response as “values‑based realism”. They are principled in defending sovereignty, territorial integrity, the UN Charter’s limits on force and human rights, but pragmatic in accepting divergent interests, incremental progress and cooperation with partners who do not share all of Canada’s values.
Canada, he said, is recalibrating relationships so their depth reflects shared values, engaging broadly with open eyes and no longer assuming that geography or alliance membership automatically guarantees prosperity and security. Sovereignty is redefined as the ability to withstand pressure, supported by shared investments and standards that lower the cost of resilience when middle powers act together rather than negotiate one‑to‑one from weakness with hegemonic states.
Domestic rebuilding and external diversification
The Carney doctrine links honest foreign policy to domestic strength and diversified external ties. At home, Canada has cut taxes on incomes, capital gains and business investment and dismantled federal barriers to interprovincial trade. They are doubling defence spending by 2030 in ways that build domestic industry, and fast‑tracking a trillion dollars of investment in energy, AI, critical minerals and trade corridors.
Abroad, Canada is diversifying with a “variable geometry” approach: a comprehensive strategic partnership with the EU (including its SAFE defence procurement scheme), twelve other trade and security deals on four continents, and new strategic partnerships with China and Qatar, alongside free trade negotiations with India, ASEAN, Thailand, the Philippines and Mercosur.
On security and global issues, Canada participates in issue‑specific coalitions: a core member of a “Coalition of the Willing” on Ukraine and a major per‑capita supporter of its defence; a firm backer of Greenland and Denmark on Arctic sovereignty; a committed NATO ally investing in radar, submarines, aircraft and ground forces. It is a promoter of a trade “bridge” between the Trans‑Pacific Partnership and the EU; organisers of G7‑anchored critical‑minerals buyers’ clubs; and collaborators on AI governance, so democracies are not forced to choose between rival hegemons and dominant tech platforms.
Canada’s capacity to pursue this agenda is justified by its assets: energy superpower status, large critical‑mineral reserves, a highly educated population, globally significant pension funds, capital, talent and substantial fiscal space, combined with values that others admire. Carney portrayed Canada as a noisy but functioning pluralist democracy, committed to sustainability and seen as a stable, long‑term partner in a volatile world.
Living in truth and middle‑power coalitions
Carney called on middle powers to “live in truth” by naming reality, acting consistently and building the institutions they claim to believe in. That means dropping the comforting but misleading language of a “rules‑based international order” that no longer operates as advertised, and instead describing the present as an era in which great powers use economic integration as coercive leverage. It also means applying the same standards to allies and rivals. His doctrine insists that governments must reduce their exposure to retaliation – through domestic economic strength and international diversification – if they want the freedom to take principled stands without fear.
In concluding, he urged middle powers to cooperate rather than compete for great‑power favour, using their collective legitimacy, integrity and commitment to rules to shape a new order. The Carney doctrine thus ends with an invitation: Canada accepts that the old order is gone and nostalgia is not a strategy. It is inviting other willing countries to join in building a denser web of cooperative arrangements that is more honest, more resilient and more just than the system it replaces.
Watch the speech in full:
More from East Anglia Bylines

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.











