• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
East Anglia Bylines
  • HOME
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Health
    • Welfare
    • World
    Owners of the wooden Dutch built yacht ordered to leave the UK.

    Soviet-style border force order Dutch couple to abandon sailing holiday and go home

    A&E

    Crisis looming for Southend Hospital and the Mid and South Essex NHS Trust

    Luton town hall

    Luton Deputy Mayor regrets Covid breach

    Liz Truss

    EU taking legal action against UK over Northern Ireland protocol: how did we get here?

    Rook

    Northern Ireland Protocol Bill results in Cambridge lab losing its EU funding

    17 May BPI occupation

    BP hypocrisy on climate challenged by Cambridge sit-in

    People in masks

    Eight changes the world needs to make to live with COVID

    Queen Elizabeth II Crossing

    Anxiety grows over viability of planned Lower Thames Crossing

    Norfolk for Europe March

    Goodbye, Leave and Remain?

    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    Stapleford Granary concert hall

    July classical events at Stapleford Granary, Cambridge

    Suffolk SketchFest is back

    Traditional beers by the Brentwood Brewing Company.

    Brentwood’s own craft beer company

    People in masks

    Eight changes the world needs to make to live with COVID

    Norwich Floods in 1912: handing a loaf to a flooded-out cottager

    Spectre of 1953 looms as East Anglia faces flood warnings

    University of East Anglia. Photo by Michael John Button via Flickr (CC BY-SA 2.0)

    A civic university for the East

    Southend Section 60 map

    Police issue Dispersal Order in Southend

    Ukraine wins Eurovision 2022

    Sam Ryder helps Eurovision’s possible return to the UK

    Robert Walpole

    Walpole: When did the end game begin?

    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • All
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    RMT Ipswich Branch

    Mick Lynch and a new wave of trade unionists

    Traditional beers by the Brentwood Brewing Company.

    Brentwood’s own craft beer company

    Sunak & Johnson

    The economics of the government’s pay disputes don’t stack

    Queen Elizabeth II Crossing

    Anxiety grows over viability of planned Lower Thames Crossing

    Rishi Sunak

    There is a solution to public sector pay disputes if the government wants to find one

    'For sale' boards.

    Housing Association “Right to Buy” proposal is ‘just wrong’ say experts

    East Anglia One windfarm

    One in three Suffolk manufacturing jobs lost since Tories came to power

    Foodbank parcels

    Hunger crisis: is it a national emergency?

    Mortgage debt.

    Sub-prime from Hollywood farce comes to UK housing

    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • All
    • Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
    Saffron Walden turf maze

    Essex town fighting health threat of poor air quality

    Latton Island campaigners

    Rich and poor dispute new Essex river crossing

    Owners of the wooden Dutch built yacht ordered to leave the UK.

    Soviet-style border force order Dutch couple to abandon sailing holiday and go home

    Fertiliser spreading

    Fertiliser – Where there’s muck…

    Stapleford Granary concert hall

    July classical events at Stapleford Granary, Cambridge

    A&E

    Crisis looming for Southend Hospital and the Mid and South Essex NHS Trust

    Suffolk SketchFest is back

    Traditional beers by the Brentwood Brewing Company.

    Brentwood’s own craft beer company

    Sailing barges, Colne estuary.

    The River Colne – where nature, history and modern life collide

    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series
No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Health
    • Welfare
    • World
    Owners of the wooden Dutch built yacht ordered to leave the UK.

    Soviet-style border force order Dutch couple to abandon sailing holiday and go home

    A&E

    Crisis looming for Southend Hospital and the Mid and South Essex NHS Trust

    Luton town hall

    Luton Deputy Mayor regrets Covid breach

    Liz Truss

    EU taking legal action against UK over Northern Ireland protocol: how did we get here?

    Rook

    Northern Ireland Protocol Bill results in Cambridge lab losing its EU funding

    17 May BPI occupation

    BP hypocrisy on climate challenged by Cambridge sit-in

    People in masks

    Eight changes the world needs to make to live with COVID

    Queen Elizabeth II Crossing

    Anxiety grows over viability of planned Lower Thames Crossing

    Norfolk for Europe March

    Goodbye, Leave and Remain?

    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    Stapleford Granary concert hall

    July classical events at Stapleford Granary, Cambridge

    Suffolk SketchFest is back

    Traditional beers by the Brentwood Brewing Company.

    Brentwood’s own craft beer company

    People in masks

    Eight changes the world needs to make to live with COVID

    Norwich Floods in 1912: handing a loaf to a flooded-out cottager

    Spectre of 1953 looms as East Anglia faces flood warnings

    University of East Anglia. Photo by Michael John Button via Flickr (CC BY-SA 2.0)

    A civic university for the East

    Southend Section 60 map

    Police issue Dispersal Order in Southend

    Ukraine wins Eurovision 2022

    Sam Ryder helps Eurovision’s possible return to the UK

    Robert Walpole

    Walpole: When did the end game begin?

    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • All
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    RMT Ipswich Branch

    Mick Lynch and a new wave of trade unionists

    Traditional beers by the Brentwood Brewing Company.

    Brentwood’s own craft beer company

    Sunak & Johnson

    The economics of the government’s pay disputes don’t stack

    Queen Elizabeth II Crossing

    Anxiety grows over viability of planned Lower Thames Crossing

    Rishi Sunak

    There is a solution to public sector pay disputes if the government wants to find one

    'For sale' boards.

    Housing Association “Right to Buy” proposal is ‘just wrong’ say experts

    East Anglia One windfarm

    One in three Suffolk manufacturing jobs lost since Tories came to power

    Foodbank parcels

    Hunger crisis: is it a national emergency?

    Mortgage debt.

    Sub-prime from Hollywood farce comes to UK housing

    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • All
    • Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
    Saffron Walden turf maze

    Essex town fighting health threat of poor air quality

    Latton Island campaigners

    Rich and poor dispute new Essex river crossing

    Owners of the wooden Dutch built yacht ordered to leave the UK.

    Soviet-style border force order Dutch couple to abandon sailing holiday and go home

    Fertiliser spreading

    Fertiliser – Where there’s muck…

    Stapleford Granary concert hall

    July classical events at Stapleford Granary, Cambridge

    A&E

    Crisis looming for Southend Hospital and the Mid and South Essex NHS Trust

    Suffolk SketchFest is back

    Traditional beers by the Brentwood Brewing Company.

    Brentwood’s own craft beer company

    Sailing barges, Colne estuary.

    The River Colne – where nature, history and modern life collide

    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series
No Result
View All Result
East Anglia Bylines
No Result
View All Result

On the legal toppling of statues

Despite government efforts, our jury system represents a significant counter-balance to the actions of an over-powerful state.

Martin WallerbyMartin Waller
January 9, 2022
in Politics
“Not guilty” Colston statue verdict. Photo by howtostartablogonline.net via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

“Not guilty” Colston statue verdict. Photo by howtostartablogonline.net via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Any number of stately homes or estates in East Anglia will have benefited from the proceeds of the slave trade – as is true of any other area in the UK. There are, however, no statues of prominent slavers in the region, as far as I am aware – East Anglia is better associated with abolitionists such as Thomas Clarkson.

Should such a statue come to light, though, would you and I be justified in pulling it to the ground – and would we get away with it? Probably, after the not guilty verdict on the four who toppled the Edward Colston statue in Bristol.

The space where Colston stood is now filled with #BlackLivesMatter signs – a powerful day in Bristol pic.twitter.com/C5v8QVcJlK

— Caitlin Hobbs (@Chobbs7) June 7, 2020

Outcry from some on the right

The verdict has aroused concern mainly among right wingers that it decriminalises the offence of criminal damage and that it was politically motivated.

Suella Braverman, the attorney-general, is among them. “Trial by jury is an important guardian of liberty & must not be undermined. However, the decision in the Colston statue case is causing confusion,” she tweeted.

It’s that “however”, isn’t it, that catches the eye? She is “carefully considering” whether to go to the Court of Appeal to “clarify the law for future cases”. She seems at least to be aware that the appeal court cannot reverse a jury verdict, which is as well given she is the most senior legal figure in government and a QC.

Yet that same government has said it will attempt to correct court rulings that it disagrees with.

Clearer guidance for judges

Braverman seems to want judges to be given clearer guidance on how to instruct juries, requiring them to ask jurors to set aside any political “woke” views when reaching a verdict. This is speculation at this stage, but this looks like one of those knee-jerk reactions aimed at appeasing the Conservative right wing. It can’t be done.

In saying this I speak as someone who has done jury service five times – don’t ask, the odds of this happening are astronomically low, and no, you can’t get off.

Any change in the law telling judges how to carry out their work will simply be ignored, if the judge in question believes it is contrary to the rights of the defendant and gets in the way of justice being served. This is because they are truly independent. In my wide experience of judges, they are extraordinarily scrupulous in ensuring jurors have all the facts they need to reach a proper verdict and are not in any way improperly influenced by anything or anyone.

Judges are constrained

A judge cannot call on a jury to bring in a guilty verdict. He or she can demand a not guilty verdict if they believe, as the case unfolds, that it has no merit.

So any attempt to gain more frequent guilty verdicts in so-called “political” trials by means of legislation will simply not work.

Jurors are, in my experience, equally scrupulous in reaching the right verdict. They are also likely to be swayed by other factors over and above the facts of the case, such as the social standing and/or possible poverty of the defendant. They make moral and/or political decisions on whether a defendant, even if he or she has carried out the acts they are accused of, should be found guilty. This seems to have happened in the Colston case, though again this is speculation.

Jurors aren’t always impartial

This is human nature. Justice would seem to require a weighing of the facts, and of those other factors. In my view, on a subject as divisive as the toppling of statues of historical figures whose actions we today disapprove of, it is unlikely a jury would reach a guilty verdict. It generally only requires three abstainers, refusing to convict, to result in a hung jury and no verdict.

If you take 12 randomly selected people, at least three, in my view, would refuse to convict in such cases, a political decision but one they are entitled to make. The decision on whether to go for a retrial is down to the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS). The rules would suggest a retrial would require “significant public interest factors”. In the real world the CPS probably wouldn’t bother, for a minor act of public damage.

I find the above rather reassuring. The jury system, as I have seen it operate over more than four decades, represents a significant counter-balance to the actions of an over-powerful state. The quality of jurors, and the effort they put into their deliberations, has in my experience improved over that period. Long may it continue.

And another thing…

Postscript: Since writing this I have been reminded of two things. One, a “political” decision such as Colston, if such it be, does not set a precedent. Each case would be judged on its merits, which is as it should be.

Two, The Bloody Code is the term that is now given to the extreme form of punishments for a large number of crimes committed in the early part of the 19th century. Hungry children could be hanged or deported for the theft of a loaf of bread. It was largely abolished and the number of capital crimes reduced partly because juries were increasingly disinclined to convict when they felt the punishment for the crime was out of all proportion to its seriousness.

At university I studied Jurisprudence, the philosophy behind the law. This pretty much changed my life, in that it made me begin to ask questions that had never before occurred to me.

One thing I learnt is that there is a lag between social change and that change being embodied in legislation. Two examples: drink driving, in my youth, was the norm. People began to become aware that deaths on the roads were being caused by drunk drivers, and that this was unacceptable. The consequence was the 1966 Road Safety Bill.

Two, homosexuality. Social attitudes towards this changed, and it was seen as unacceptable for gay people to be prosecuted and locked up. The consequence was the Sexual Offences Act 1967.

Legislation driven by social attitudes

The conclusion is that legislation driving social change can be spurred by changing social attitudes, and this, in the case of The Bloody Code, can be in part driven by jurors refusing to accept the law as it is set down by Parliament.

It works the other way around, though. Negative social changes, as some would see them, people moving towards more extreme, illiberal views, can drive harsh, illiberal legislation. This is subjective, in that different people may have different views on what is harsh and illiberal. But the danger is that an authoritarian government may use those changing social views as a way of overturning those checks and balances that protect our basic freedoms.

Like undermining jury trials… which is where we came in, I think.

Tags: Justice
Previous Post

The climate change sceptics may have changed their clothes, but they still don’t have the answers for the future

Next Post

Learn to live with Covid

Martin Waller

Martin Waller

Martin Waller worked for The Times as a financial writer for some three decades. He is now retired and living in Suffolk

Related Posts

House of Commons
Politics

GrubbyGates

byMadge McClary
July 3, 2022
Keir Starmer
Politics

Security matters for Labour

byStephen McNair
June 27, 2022
Liz Truss
Brexit

EU taking legal action against UK over Northern Ireland protocol: how did we get here?

byProf Nikos Skoutaris
June 26, 2022
Mr Pecksniff (Social Media)
Pecksniff

Pecksniff’s Diary

byEast Anglia Bylines
June 24, 2022
Sunak & Johnson
Economics

The economics of the government’s pay disputes don’t stack

byProf Richard Murphy
June 24, 2022
Next Post
“Learn to live with Covid”. Art by Dormouse

Learn to live with Covid

Want to support us?

Can you help East Anglia Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

DONATE

Sign up to our newsletter

If you would like to receive the East Anglia Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

NEWSLETTER

LATEST

House of Commons

GrubbyGates

July 3, 2022
Saffron Walden turf maze

Essex town fighting health threat of poor air quality

July 3, 2022
Latton Island campaigners

Rich and poor dispute new Essex river crossing

July 2, 2022
Mr Pecksniff (Social Media)

Pecksniff’s Diary

July 1, 2022

MOST READ

Owners of the wooden Dutch built yacht ordered to leave the UK.

Soviet-style border force order Dutch couple to abandon sailing holiday and go home

July 1, 2022
Saffron Walden turf maze

Essex town fighting health threat of poor air quality

July 3, 2022
Boris Johnson and his cabinet.

Our government is killing democracy by a thousand cuts

May 3, 2022
House of Commons

GrubbyGates

July 3, 2022

Tags

Activism Art Brexit Business Cambridgeshire Climate Community COP26 Culture Democracy Development Economics Economy Education Employment Energy Environment Farming Health Humour Hymns International Women's Day Justice Letters Local elections 2022 Local government National Grid NHS Norfolk Pandemic Partygate Party politics Pecksniff Poetry Politics Poverty Rivers of East Anglia Sewage Sizewell Social care Suffolk Ukraine VAWG Welfare Wildlife
East Anglia Bylines

East Anglia Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in East Anglia and beyond.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About us
    • Contact us
    • Bylines Network
    • Complaints
    • Newsletter
    • Privacy Policy
    • Donate
  • UK
  • Anglia
  • About us
  • UK
  • Anglia

© 2022 East Anglia Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • East Anglia
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series

© 2022 East Anglia Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In