Remember the pandemic? The loneliness, uncertainty, fear, and for some, illness, or death. The frantic purchasing of PPE. The desperate vying of country against country to get Covid-19 vaccines, regardless of cost. Our governments have admitted they made mistakes. They have, most of them, promised to do their best not to repeat them. But are these just words?
The World Health Organisation (WHO) is endeavouring to negotiate a ‘Pandemic Treaty’: an international agreement on pandemic prevention, preparedness and response. The text was supposed to be ratified on 9 May. Agreement has largely been reached on some aspects. But despite repeated pleas by the WHO to “get this done”, it seems, as with all other international treaties, that this one is proving extremely tricky.
All for one, and one for all
“The draft pandemic agreement is a kind of non-proliferation accord: a declaration that we will help each other and work together in the event of a new public health crisis.” writes former Prime Minister Gordon Brown. “The overarching lesson from the COVID-19 pandemic – one that we learned the hard way – is that no one is safe anywhere until everyone is safe everywhere.”
Among the highly diplomatic and technical negotiations, there is a concern that the primary intent of the Pandemic Treaty is lost. Its aim is to protect all people, in all countries, no matter how rich or poor, from harm. But with diplomatic attention focused on Gaza, Ukraine and Russia, coupled with upcoming elections, the political urgency and the willingness of political leaders to cooperate, is severely strained.
Progress so far
Agreement has largely been reached on some aspects: Articles 6 (preparedness); 7 (workforce); 8 (communication); 9 (research and development); 10 (diversified production); 11 (tech transfer); 13 (supply chain); 13bis (procurement); 17 (whole of government); 19 (cooperation).

Some of the most difficult issues still lack consensus: One Health (Articles 4 and 5); pathogen access and benefit-sharing, PABS (Article 12); financing (Article 20).
The Lancet has described the treaty’s draft text from October 2023 as “filled with platitudes, caveats, and the term ‘where appropriate’.”
The word ‘equity’ appears nine times in the draft text, including as a guiding principle of the whole Pandemic Treaty. But in reality, Article 12 stipulates that the WHO would have access to only 20% of ‘pandemic-related products’ for distribution based on public health risks and needs. The other 80%, whether vaccines, treatments, or diagnosis, “would be prey to the international scramble seen in COVID-19 that saw vital health technologies sold to the highest bidder,” writes The Lancet.
The morality of only 20% being allocated to the poorest countries, where most of the world’s population lives, is, in The Lancet’s words, “shameful, unjust and inequitable.”
The pharmaceutical industry may be willing to share vaccines and treatments, but probably not at any price. Wealthy countries with significant pharmaceutical companies will want clauses on the sharing of intellectual property for products such as vaccines to be voluntary, not obligatory.
Gaslighting
One aspect that concerns Gordon Brown, is the “flagrant falsehoods being circulated that the WHO has already abandoned the treaty and is giving up on it.”

In particular, he cites the false allegation, widely circulated by conspiracy theorists, encouraged by Nigel Farage, and Andrea Jenkyns, that under the Pandemic Treaty, the WHO will be “empowered to strip member states of sovereignty, monitor people’s movements through digital passports, and deploy armed troops to enforce mandatory vaccinations and lockdowns.”
In fact, the WHO would not be able to exert far-reaching authority over countries and their citizens during a public-health emergency, and the organization itself is not interested in pursuing a power grab.
Is there a route to success?
The latest plan is to resume negotiations in the next days. Whatever progress is made, one aspect that will be essential is governance – the need for independent monitoring to confirm that countries are complying with their commitments.
Nina Schwalbe, a global public health expert in the field of vaccines and immunization, has expressed concern that all indications suggest that the governance and accountability mechanisms of the treaty are being undermined. The consequence of this is a pandemic treaty with little in the way of clear enforceable obligations to prevent zoonotic disease outbreaks, strengthen health systems, or counter disinformation.
The view of The Lancet is that the G7 countries must put aside their vested interests and finally understand that in a pandemic, it is not possible to protect only your own citizens – the health of one depends on the health of all:
A handful of powerful countries are sabotaging the best chance to translate the lessons from the Covid-19 pandemic into legally binding commitments that will protect us all.
Whether the Pandemic Treaty will be finalized at the 77th World Health Assembly, which starts on 27 May, is very much in the balance.









