• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9771
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
East Anglia Bylines
Advertisement
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Development
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series
No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Development
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series
No Result
View All Result
East Anglia Bylines
Home REGIONS Anglia

Is cooperation replacing confrontation in our politics?

In councils across East Anglia, single party rule is being replaced by coalitions. Will this produce better government?

Stephen McNair by Stephen McNair
8 October 2023
in Anglia, Democracy, Party politics
Reading Time: 7 mins read
A A
Eight people holding each others wrists in a circle to represent cooperation.

Photo credit: image by pikist. public domain

Share on Bluesky

In a democracy we vote, and our votes determine who forms the government. Except we don’t. In reality, at national and local levels, the only votes which count are in a small number of marginal places, and political parties focus almost all their efforts on the people who live there.

Everywhere else voters can be ignored, because their MPs and councillors are elected repeatedly with comfortable majorities. So how unfair is this, and how different would the result be at national or local level, if our parliament and councils reflected the actual votes cast?

The national picture

Since 1945, the Conservatives have been in power for 64% of the time, despite the fact that a majority of voters have always voted in national elections for parties to their left. Most recently, in 2019, the Conservatives won 43% of the vote share, but 56% of the seats in Parliament.

There are two simple reasons for this. First, to win a seat a candidate does not need a majority of the votes, only the largest number in that constituency. Usually, the broad left vote is split between Labour and Liberal Democrats, while the right wing vote unifies round a single party. So in most constituencies, the Conservative wins.

The second reason is our “first past the post” electoral system. Labour voters are heavily concentrated in a relatively small group of urban areas. So the typical Labour MP is elected with a very large majorities, but there are fewer of them. By contrast, Conservative voters are spread more evenly across the country, where they can win with smaller majorities. Overall, substantial numbers in rural constituencies vote Labour, but spread around, they are regularly outweighed in individual constituencies.

As a result the average number of votes cast for the winning MP in 2019 varies by party:

Conservative
Labour
LibDem
Green

38,264
50,835
336,000
865,697

And, to demonstrate the inequity, the 4 million people who voted for UKIP at its peak were so widely spread that they elected no MPs at all.

As its advocates argue, first past the post usually ensures clear results, and avoids messy coalitions. But it is clear that at national level, it does not accurately reflect the views of voters.

Are local elections any fairer?

The first past the post problem applies equally in local elections, where the anomalies are even more dramatic, but often hidden, because different councils elect on different cycles. In East Anglia, 20 of our 45 councils elect a third of their councillors every year, while 25 elect them all every four years. So change happens faster in some places than others.

In the East of England, in the last elections before 2023 there were 21 districts where the mismatch between vote share and seat share was more than 20 points. The gap was greatest in St Albans, where the LibDems held 89% of the seats with only 48% of the votes. In the region, there were only four districts where the gap was less than 5%. Although the gaps were smaller in 2023, they were still significant, averaging 10%.

Until May 2023, the Conservatives had dominated this region, controlling more than half the councils. However, this year their vote share across the region fell from 46% to 35%, and they lost control of 13 councils. All other parties increased their vote share, Labour’s rose by 5%, and the Greens won their first council. But most striking was the rise in councils where no single party had a majority, and where some sort of coalition is now in charge (shown in grey on the map).

A proportional system might deliver different results in East Anglia

We cannot be sure whether a proportional election would produce different results in East Anglia. People would behave differently if they knew that the system was proportional, especially if they were allowed to rank candidates, rather than simply voting for one. However, we can make a rough estimate of possible changes using the 2023 voting figures.

On this basis in almost two thirds of districts (28) the largest party would have won fewer seats on a proportional basis than they did under first past the post. In the average district this would have reduced that party’s tally of councillors by 4 – enough to tip the balance of control in some councils.

On this basis there are five districts where a proportional result might have been different. In all five the proportional result would have resulted in a council with no overall political control. The Conservatives would have lost Braintree, Breckland and East Cambridgeshire. The Liberal Democrats would have lost Dacorum. The Residents for Uttlesford party would have lost Uttlesford.

Coalitions and minority rule

Most striking is the number of councils now governed by some form of coalition. Before last May’s elections there were 9 councils in the region where no single party had a majority. In May (under first past the post), that number increased to 20. Had this year’s election been proportional, the number might have risen further, to 24 – half the councils in the region. In this situation, the parties have to negotiate some form of agreement, which may be a formal coalition or something less formal. In all these cases they have to agree on a leader.

The table shows which party controlled each of these Districts before last May, what the outcome of the May election was, what might be a proportional result, and which party currently leads the council.

For a long time, voters in the East of England have tended to vote Conservative, and first past the post has emphasised that, giving them clear control of most councils. In 2023 that broke down, producing far more hung councils. Clearly a proportional electoral system would increase that effect.

We now have 20 councils in the region operating as coalitions or with minority rule. Each of the five parties is leading at least 2 of these coalitions, with a variety of partners. We will see, over the next few years, how well that works. Perhaps the negotiations inherent in coalition will give us more stable long-term government, and reflect what we really want, better than the Conservative hegemony of recent years, or the see-sawing politics we have lived with at national level.

It is an important experiment, which could have lessons for national electoral reform. But will an incoming government want to listen, and will it dare grasp the nettle?


More from East Anglia Bylines

Lowestoft Town Hall
Democracy

Local elections: East Anglia’s little red wall

by Stephen McNair
24 April 2023
Tags: GreensLabourLibDemsLocal government
Previous Post

Pecksniff’s Diary

Next Post

A pension edifice built on sand. Is anyone noticing?

Stephen McNair

Stephen McNair

Stephen McNair is a member of the EAB editorial team, living in Norfolk. Now retired, he spent most of his career working on education policy, especially learning and work, at local, national and international level. He is Emeritus Professor of Education at the University of Surrey, and previously a Director of the National Institute for Adult Continuing Education. After 'retiring' he spent five years chairing a European research committee on demographic change.

Related Posts

Eleven East Anglia Bylines volunteers gathered around pub tables in Norwich, smiling towards the camera, with large windows behind them.
Anglia

Good news for independent journalism in East Anglia – and for you

by Anna Damski
6 November 2026
Four slightly tilted panels showing the headquarters of Essex, Cambridgeshire, Norfolk and Suffolk county councils, each identified by its council logo, against a textured grey background.
Anglia

East Anglia’s council shake-up is back on – but a year later

by East Anglia Bylines
4 November 2026
Houses stand close to the edge of a steep, eroding sandy cliff above the beach at Thorpeness, Suffolk.
Anglia

Dredging for profit but losing our villages?

by Rachel Fulcher
30 October 2026
A person holds a small model house and a set of keys in their outstretched hands
Business

Why this Tory obsession with inheritance tax?

by Prof Richard Murphy
20 October 2026
The palace of Westminster on fire. An impressionistic image, viewed from across the river. The white stonework of Westminster Bridge on the right of the image glows orange from half way across the river as it reflects the huge flames from the fire. There are dense crowds on the shore in front of the artist, and boats with more spectators on the river.
Democracy

Westminster: it’s time for reform from the ground up

by Calix Eden
16 October 2026
Next Post
Worried pensioner reading papers at his desk

A pension edifice built on sand. Is anyone noticing?

SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

Tags

Activism Brexit Cartoons Christmas Climate Community Conservation Conservatives Democracy Economy Elections Environment EU Farming General Election 2024 Government Health History Housing Labour Letters Local government Net zero NHS Norwich Opinion Our place in Europe Party politics Pecksniff Politics Polling Pollution Poverty Reform UK Renewables Sewage Social care Something for the weekend Tax Trump Ukraine Voting Wealth Wildlife Women
East Anglia Bylines

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in East Anglia and beyond.

East Anglia Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Letters
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2021-2026 East Anglia Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9771

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Health
    • Education
    • World
  • Politics
    • Local government
    • Justice
    • Activism
  • Climate
    • Environment
  • Lifestyle
    • Community
    • Culture
    • History
    • Humour
    • Property
  • Business
    • Development
    • Economics
    • Finance
    • Transport
    • Farming
  • ANGLIA
    • Bedfordshire
    • Cambridgeshire
    • Essex
    • Hertfordshire
    • Norfolk
    • Suffolk
  • Series

Newsletter sign up

Crowdfunder

© 2021-2026 East Anglia Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9771