
The US has an unhappy record in upholding democracy, and its commitment has often seemed reluctant and transactional. In comparison, the EU’s principles of upholding human dignity, human rights, freedom, democracy, equality and the rule of law seem hopelessly out-of-step with current events.
America’s frequent contempt for Europe and its culture has been based on a presumption of weakness: what America sees as a failure to look after number one. Now, Donald Trump has made that plain. He feels contempt for what Europe represents, not least because he knows he can get away with his lebensraum: aggressive imperialism with thoughts only for the further aggrandisement of the US.
For the time being.
This leaves both Britain and the EU with almost literally impossible choices to make in response. But whereas the EU clearly bridles at the contempt Trump doesn’t bother to hide, Keir Starmer chooses to ignore it. In the short term it is difficult to judge which is likely, if either, to bear any success.
The PM is in no position to antagonise the president and understandably eschews the self-indulgent demands that he blow raspberries instead. But while he prefers to turn the other cheek, the British public do not. There is room for nuance, but the Jesuitical blather from his ministers avoids it and only makes the government look ridiculous.
Kowtowing to the US can only be a mariage de convenance, unless the PM is preparing to offer up Britain as America’s 51st state. Behind the scenes, he has to be working feverishly to find new alliances – and that can only realistically involve the EU. Yet he has declared this week (when he really didn’t need to) that the US remains Britain’s most important ally. It seems a rebuttal of any idea of returning to Europe, so we (and the EU) know where we stand.
We would like to believe that the government may be playing a shrewd game, but there is no evidence of it. The PM has never made any honest attempt to return to the embrace of the EU and there is simply no possibility of drawing closer to Europe while Keir Starmer is PM. He has to go.
*
During the aftermath of the fall of the Berlin wall, your diarist became involved in advising some of the smaller countries of the former Soviet bloc. At Chatham House receptions, my dears, European ambassadors hung upon your diarist’s every word. Yet however flattering, this was not, it has reluctantly to be admitted, an acknowledgement of the Pecksniff wisdom. No. Being British and moving in political circles, it was just hoped there was a chance your diarist might know Tony Blair.

That hope was to be disappointed. At the time, Mr Blair was cosplaying God, and his charisma and apparent Midas touch carried all before him. Every diplomat and politician in Europe wanted to touch his raiment and, if possible, get that priceless posed picture with him.
Their immediate exhilaration of freedom from Soviet vassalage had soon become afflicted by the realisation that it was a big, cold and dangerous world out there in which to be a little fish. They all wanted desperately to feel the warm embrace that would come of membership of the EU and NATO, and Mr Blair’s imprimatur on their applications would guarantee success.
The reason for this anecdote is that, at the moment, it would seem Britain is in a similar position. Adrift and out in the cold, but in our case still reluctant to admit to being Billy No-Mates.
*

So put down that pint for a moment, dear reader, and let us consider why the response to the Trump atrocities from Britain and the members of the EU have differed. The anecdote above may give us a clue. The member states of the EU act in accordance with the EU’s proud principles and are confident in expressing their views within the warm glow of collegiate solidarity that comes from 27 countries having come together to pursue the same goals. It is these goals which provide the sense of identity, an identity which they are prepared to defend.
Yet these days, we would be hard put to define Britain’s identity – let alone England’s. There is another reason though. With that sense of solidarity comes an awareness of strength. Whatever threats may come from Donald Trump, they can be met by 27 countries standing together. But Britain, aloof in our isolationist delusions, has chosen to set sail all alone, on what are suddenly dangerously uncharted seas. Like those former countries of the Soviet bloc, we are becoming all too aware of just how vulnerable we are, and what a dangerous world it is for a country with few friends and nobody to rely on.
So we are scared, and rightly so. The truth is that all alone and determined to have no truck with EU membership, Keir Starmer simply daren’t stand up to Donald Trump. Now compare the nationalist trumpetings about identity from our politicians, with the reality. Humiliating, isn’t it?
*

It is of at least anthropological interest to recall a previous vaunted special relationship between an American president and a British prime minister, and the response the PM gave when confronted with a similar problem: the US invasion of Grenada. Margaret Thatcher told Ronald Reagan:
“We in the Western democracies use our force to defend our way of life. We do not use it to walk into other people’s countries, independent sovereign territories… If you are pronouncing a new law that wherever Communism reigns against the will of the people… there the United States shall enter, then we are going to have really terrible wars in the world.”
*
At the moment we seem powerless in the face of something which, frankly, we could see coming but our politicians preferred to ignore. Turning away from Donald Trump’s America was too scary, too difficult to deal with. It would involve confronting our delusions, and dramatic change. This week East Anglia Bylines published an article called Hannah Arendt and the new age of populism, about the thinking of Arendt, a German Jew who fled her country for the US during the war. The author, Christopher Finlay, writes:
“Perhaps her most important lesson is about trying to understand something radically new using outdated concepts – ‘interpreting history by commonplaces’ as Arendt called it. Faced with a jarringly new style of politics, there is a temptation to explain it away as mere nationalistic excess, for instance. Or as an understandable expression of economic disappointment and one readily addressed with economic remedies.
“By trying to reduce it to familiar terms, Arendt said ‘the impact of reality and the shock of experience were no longer felt’, and people failed to resist when they most needed to.”
So we hear that Keir Starmer has been jollying his cabinet along with tales of how all they have to do is keep their nerve and keep on doing what they are doing, and everything will turn out right.
*
So what does the Trump attack and plundering of Venezuela mean for Britain’s right-wing politicians? They are in some difficulty, since their constant bathing in the Trump hubris has led them inevitably into having to confront a situation in which their hero has become anathema to a huge majority of the British electorate. This situation was always likely to arise, sooner or later, and choosing a line to take requires delicacy.
Nigel Farage spots the bear trap and admits that the US action in Venezuela was “unorthodox and contrary to international law”, an abrupt handbrake turn for one of Donald Trump’s most obsequious admirers. You can smell the rubber. Meanwhile, we can guess almost word-for-word the discussion at the Tories’ strategy meeting. How to continue to flounce against the Starmer government without admitting folly in putting all their eggs in Mr Trump’s basket?

So they went for ‘morally right even if legally wrong’, though Kemi Badenoch (NW Essex) is at pains not to stress the last bit. She admits only that it “raises serious questions about the rules-based order” – questions clearly Ms Badenoch will not be at pains to try to answer.
The one absent voice is from Liz Truss, now languishing in the bas fonds of politics and on this subject suddenly with nothing to say. She has incurred criticism in recent weeks for her blatant attacks on Britain, prompting one of the region’s MPs to describe her to Pecksniff as “Lady Haw-Haw”.
*
Every week though, Pecksniff is faced with the same conundrum: how much oxygen to give to the endless megaphone of accusations and boasts from Reform and all points right? But then, where are the plausible (let alone compelling) narratives from the left? There is only disarray. So when the only choice seems to be between competing versions of fascism, racism and white supremacy, what is the electorate to do?
*
The combined scheme of all those things which make up everyday political life provide a slow and relentless momentum, which over time becomes impossible to escape. Important problems prove impossible to grasp, let alone solve. So ministers, and below them the poor bloody infantry of backbench MPs are seduced, with whatever reluctance, into accepting the cosmetic as the only thing they can affect.
They are encouraged in this by much of the news media, for whom a fleeting headline describes the extent of their ambition. The meat and drink of people’s lives is reduced to showbiz. This is the politics of Steve Reed and others in the cabinet, and a million miles from what the electorate want from their politicians. There are good people in parliament, but they seem made impotent by the grinding necessities of power.
*
One of the issues which successive dilatory governments have ignored is the growing influence of Russia and other foreign powers (which certainly include the US). We wanted their billionaires’ money and chose not to ask too many questions. So audacious though it may sound, East Anglia Bylines and the wise men have undertaken to carry out our own investigations.
From our long-running series on Europe we have a number of informed contacts among diplomats and others, who we are confident will be prepared to spill a number of beans. If we are serious about trying to resurrect our democracy, it is important that we start at the roots and determine just who does run the country. Democracy begins in the saloon bar. It is far too important to be left to politicians.
*
We are unlikely to find the narrative we seek from the Fabian Society, a Labour thinktank but which has a creditable reputation for knowing its own mind. However, its head, Joe Dromey, is dismissive of the rise of the Green Party, and complains that Greens leader Zack Polanski offers only “unicorns” and “fantasy solutions”. Hardly an original observation, but not necessarily the worse for that. Yet where are the Fabians’ solutions, the ideas that will make Mr Polanski’s claims irrelevant?
“We need to demonstrate competence, and that’s most obviously around small boats,” says Mr Dromey. “But the government also needs to demonstrate and expose that Reform do not speak for the British public on immigration. I think on that latter one, we’ve not done that enough. We should go harder on that.”
Harder on what, exactly? Harder on enforcing the antagonism to small boats? A radical approach would be to recognise that actually we desperately need more immigration. But the Labour Party doesn’t do radical anymore. Nor apparently does its favoured thinktank do much thinking.
*
But enough of this. From what seems long ago, before Christmas, your diarist has treasured a fragile little story of hope. After the bullying invasion of Epping by fascist thugs over refugees taking shelter in a local hotel, neighbours formed a choir to sing carols outside their windows.
*
Those ever alert over the Christmas festivities and with quills ready sharpened were Malcolm Lynn, Liz Crosbie, Celina Błędowska, James Porter, David Patey, Karl Whiteman, Helen Forte, Kate Viscardi, Mark Popay and Stace Richards.
<<< Previous Pecksniff’s Diary
More from East Anglia Bylines

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.










