
For two years, Pecksniff has been claiming that Labour’s position on Brexit would have to change before 2029. Now, in what readers – red in tooth and claw – may feel is a somewhat tardy admission of its disastrous effects on the economy, it has.
First, the Max Headroom look-alike, Wes Streeting declares, “I’m glad we can now talk about Brexit,” when only a few months ago he dismissed the subject. The phrasing is interesting. He means ‘I’m glad we’re now allowed to talk about Brexit’, and speaks of his “frustration” at having been unable to speak out. The omertà imposed by No.10 has been lifted.
The PM is hoping to carry his bat into the next parliament, yet he is the worst rated PM in history. Another catastrophically unpopular budget may see Labour drop to fifth and last place in the polls. So where else is there to go? What else is there to do?
Labour’s strategy has been to appeal to their now unwilling traditional voters and refuse to accept evidence of the embourgeoisement of the party – that the middle and professional classes are more likely to vote Labour now. But it is unlikely this strategy has changed (unless Darren Jones has something to do with it). Too many reputations rest on it. So it will be tinkering and hoping that the advantage of being able to attack Nigel Farage as Mr Brexit will outweigh undermining its own position.
But at last the dam is breached. Brexit is back on the agenda.
*
A reader from the Netherlands appealed to Pecksniff this week to explain what had gone wrong with British politics. This was your diarist’s attempt at explanation:
Like a priest who to his terror finds he has lost his faith, both Labour and Conservatives realise they no longer believe what they have been telling the electorate. Worse, they realise the voters don’t believe it either. But the parties have to pretend, because the alternative is to admit to irrelevance.
But while Labour and Tories try to avoid discussing what they no longer believe in, the voters are keen to talk, to find a party which does actually believe in something. One is Reform, and increasingly the other is the Greens. At this rate we may find ourselves leading up to the next election having both government and official opposition who the voters have all but overlooked.
*
This week the Greens passed the 115,000 membership-mark (and it was 100,000 at the beginning of the week). So they have more members than the Liberal Democrats (60,000) and are within making obscene gestures distance of the Tories (believed to be 120,000 and falling rapidly). In the few weeks since Zack Polanski’s election as leader, membership has increased by more than half. But are these the party’s salad days? Are they ready to deal with the seamy realities of politics?

While campaigning, Mr Polanski promised to “pick fights”. This was a man who apparently wasn’t scared of taking a position and defending it, a decidedly novel undertaking. Whatever the other merits of the party and its policies, it is hardly surprising that many voters respond to a politician who declares he stands for something, almost anything, after recent years when political rivals have seen a declaration of principles as something to be avoided in case it might offend somebody.
*
Pecksniff has thus far welcomed Zack Polanski’s enthusiasm, whilst retaining some doubts. Our man has shown he can talk the talk, though he still has to prove he can walk the walk. But winning the confidence of so many new members no doubt counts for considerably more than meeting the approval of a prolix and discursive political diarist, so a hat tip towards Mr Polanski seems in order.
*
Meanwhile, what have those scamps at the Liberal Democrats been up to this week? Well, Daisy Cooper (St Albans) has been trying to save our democracy, which is nice. It seems police stopped Tommy Robinson in his Bentley and found several thousand quid in the boot. He refused to reveal his phone pin number, and he has subsequently been charged with allegedly failing to comply with orders from the counter-terrorism police.

But he let slip that his legal costs are being paid by Elon Musk, and at PMQs Ms Cooper called for MI5 to investigate, arguing reasonably that if he had said the same about Vladimir Putin, the Government would act.
Recent governments have given the impression they almost connived at the corruption of our democracy (and it seems quite possible that one or two of their members actually did). The present government give the impression that standing up for democracy is too difficult and far too radical, when a bit of tinkering here and there might get us by. So we should be grateful for those MPs who take their role seriously.
*

The present Labour Party – and its attitudes as a government – would be regarded with misgiving by its predecessors, and contradicts the ideals for which most members joined. So Pecksniff has been asking Labour members among our intelligencers to ask around and help answer a pressing question … Where is there internal opposition to what is happening?
The outcome claims no particular credibility, other than that questions were asked of members in probably over 20 constituencies, including around a dozen Labour parties in the east region. However unrepresentative the sample, it might be assumed that if there were stirrings of some sort against the government’s politics on Europe, immigrants, benefits or other issues, at least somebody might have heard of it.
But there seems none. Some respondents expressed unease but were unhappy talking about it, and saw nothing they could do. A common response was: “I’m still a reluctant member”. A few are putting their faith instead in Your Party, which is rather like believing in Father Christmas. A good few have slipped away to join the Greens. A common response was “Something needs to happen at leadership level”, though nobody seemed to know quite what.
*

Pecksniff forecast trouble for Starmer from an unwieldy majority. But that mistakenly supposed some stirring of the blood among Labour members. Their complacency affects how effective backbench MPs can be in making their own arguments against government policies with which they disagree. MPs rely on support from their own local party. It might take a brave MP, then, to set off on the perilous journey to confront his or her own government without it.
*
One of the troubles with ‘Your Party’ even as a temporary name is that it looks like a blank space to be filled in on a pro forma. But never fear, Jeremy Corbyn has announced there is to be a conference in November, to hear the voice of the people! A hall full of belligerent lefties from the myriad existing parties arguing for competing motions on whose turn it is to make the tea is just what the revolution needs.

Schisms…? The Communist Party of Britain, New Communist Party of Britain, Communist Party of Great Britain (Marxist Leninist), Revolutionary Communist Party of Britain (Marxist Leninist) and the rest. The omens are not propitious – it is going to resemble an advance dressing station on the Somme.
Idealogues assume blithely that ‘the people’ speak with one voice. (They always do in Das Kapital, after all.) Whereas inconveniently they speak with myriad different voices. So what does the true revolutionary do to solve this conundrum?
He sets up committees.
Or ‘assemblies’ as they are apparently to be called.
The committees naturally won’t agree on what represents the true vox populi, so they will each split into competing caucuses, only they in turn won’t agree which pub to meet in.
But then, even the November shindig itself now looks in doubt. This week the New Statesman reports that, in spite of attempts at unity, “Zarah Sultana and Jeremy Corbyn can’t even share a green room”.
*

Opinion polls seem to suggest that perhaps Reform may be stalling. Where the party wields power in local councils, their reputation for intelligence, competence, honesty or even a grasp of the simple canons of civilised behaviour is left not entirely untarnished. Then there are the Russian links and withdrawing their promise to make £93 billion in tax cuts. Much of the party’s success has come from momentum, driven by an unquestioning media. So a loss of momentum and thus the suggestion that Reform are not all-conquering, could prove a serious problem.
But also, perhaps because of Zack Polanski’s reportedly strong showing on Question Time, the Reform leadership seem to be rattled over the Greens. On the face of it there should be no crossover, but politics is rarely rational. Many avowed Reform voters, for example, bizarrely oppose many of that party’s policies. But much of their support probably comes from the politically uninvolved, who just want to give the established (and establishment) parties a kicking. If this is so, then another even newer kid on the block is likely to prove an attraction – and a potential threat to Reform.
Have Reform seen some polls which have set alarm bells ringing? For the first time, your diarist senses that the party may be concerned at losing traction.
*
This idea may seem eccentric, though it is delightfully Green. Party members at their recent conference were all given a yellow card, setting out how they were expected to behave to each other. It says:
“The Green Party is committed to an environment free of racism, sexism, disablism, homophobia, transphobia, religious discrimination and all other types of discrimination. Please use this card to challenge these types of discrimination and raise awareness of any issues to the chair.”
It is tempting to see the card as hoping to have the equivalent effect of brandishing a crucifix in the face of a vampire. But how would this be greeted by members of other parties, one wonders? Presumably at Reform, the wording would point out that these characteristics were to be expected, and anybody not fulfilling them would be thrown out.
*

Priti Patel (Witham) believes Donald Trump should have won the Nobel Peace Prize. Not for the first time we find ourselves puzzled as to quite what she is up to. Mr Trump is as popular in this country as haemorrhoids. If she is trying – as they say in Suffolk – to “bait his maggots”, then why? If not, then who is she trying to attract?
Surely she isn’t trying again to be Tory leader? My dears, how many times is it now? Ms Patel is becoming the Edie ‘the Eagle’ Edwards of political leadership. To the embarrassment of political observers for what seems decades, her name is always thrust forward in Tory leadership contests – about every other Tuesday. And it is always the first that the Tories reject.
*
Finally, we are indebted to the Bedford Independent for a most encouraging news story. A group of eight women identifying themselves as members of the Citizens Arrest Network accosted the chief executive of Anglian Water, Mark Thurston (annual salary £720,000), at a London railway station and attempted a citizen’s arrest, on charges of pollution and public accountability. Police attended the scene and Mr Thurston was fortunately delayed for an hour before the protest ended. (Note to CAN: must try harder.)
Your diarist would never dream of suggesting readers pump raw sewage through the company’s letterbox, (mostly because the editor would not approve), but this is an effective alternative. Pecksniff would hope that readers in their thousands will now join this most excellent organisation, stuff their coffers and make it their business to discomfort others who are stupendously overpaid in the supposed service of public utilities, but whose primary aim is to make obscene profits for the invisible corporations who continue to cheat us.

*
This week’s eavesdroppers were James Porter, Karl Whiteman, Liz Crosbie, Mary Marshall, Celina Błędowska, Linda Buckmaster and Malcolm Lynn.
<<< Previous Pecksniff’s Diary











