
Last July, following the general election, Pecksniff observed that it was likely Labour wouldn’t provide the docile lobby fodder which had sometimes seemed to be the case previously. And so it has proved this week. As the final flourish is put upon this diary and the last curlicue blotted, we still don’t know the final outcome of the Labour revolt against their government’s plans to cut disability benefits. More than 125 Labour MPs signed an amendment which effectively would have killed the bill, and it is clear they have won. The government blinked first.
It is also clear that Keir Starmer has taken it badly. He sets at nought his MPs’ passionate adherence to the principles on which they were elected, dismissing them as merely “noises off”. It is difficult to think of a more insensitive and callous disregard for those ideals he himself is presumed to embody. For all that the government is taking refuge in the now placatory language of work and pensions secretary Liz Kendall, the PM’s earlier words could not fail to strike a minatory note. He had, after all, threatened to deselect the rebels, for holding true to their principles – and to what were assumed to be his. But you can bully half a dozen: not 125.
This particular dispute is all but over, it seems, but be sure this is only the beginning. There will be those in No.10 who hate the rebels with the heat of a thousand suns and will do all they can to do them down. The rebels meanwhile have felt their strength. That noise you hear is a resounding raspberry from the 2024 cohort, who have perhaps remembered what they came into parliament for.
*
Parliamentary rebellions come and go, but this one has been on the stocks since soon after last July’s election. They have had a year to evaluate it and yet failed to take account of the passions on their back benches – in fact failed even to talk to them about it by some accounts. Ironically, as we go to press on Friday, No.10 claims “this is a government that listens”.

What makes this rebellion special is that it is probably driven by the many new MPs, who perhaps are not so cowed as the old lags. Also, this revolt has headed by four chairs of select committees – all of them women, incidentally – so that added some additional gravitas. Then as the party whips turned up the screws, it only added new names to the list.
There seems a gulf between the government and the rest of its MPs. They have a huge if rather misleading majority: they won only 34% of the vote, just 1.6% more than in the party’s catastrophic defeat in 2019. Most of their MPs are new, often with small majorities, and they want to make their mark while they are there. And with an eye on keeping their seat they are probably more likely to be guided by their voters than the demands of the whips.
So we should expect much more internal opposition to Keir Starmer’s plans, and we should not be surprised to find it becoming increasingly organised.
*
The man apparently most held responsible for this government humiliation – as he is at the moment for almost everything – is the PM’s chief of staff, Morgan McSweeney. He is the self-appointed Witchfinder General against the left, credited by the Starmer camp with being the hierophant who interprets the secret mysteries of how to win elections. Others are not convinced, (which number includes your humble servant.)
But it is claimed Mr McSweeney’s star is on the wane, a suggestion perhaps confirmed this week by an extraordinary whisper from within the hallowed portals of No.10. According to the Financial Times, an ‘ally’ of Pat McFadden, the PM’s fixer and Glaswegian hard man, whispers: “Pat believes we should have a big national message. It’s never a good idea to choose between one group of voters and another. Blue Labour is not Pat’s thing — it’s more Morgan’s thing.”
There is a lot to savour in this one aside, but at core it means Mr McFadden is prepared to put his head above the parapet; and when a Weegie sticks his head out it is often to deliver the ‘Glasgow kiss’.
*
The Labour Party has 403 MPs. The official opposition is of course the Conservatives, who have 120. But of those 403 Labour MPs, 125 were prepared to bring down their own government.
So you will note there are more Labour rebels than there are Tories, who anyway couldn’t decide whether to vote against the government or support it. In the end they left it to Kemi Badenoch (NW Essex) to decide for them, but she was no clearer about what her party stands for than they were. So it seems the real opposition has become the Labour rebels – a possibility which we may be sure has not been overlooked within No.10.
They have more votes than the Tories, and are certainly making a much more effective opposition than them. So, rarely have both parties been in a more humiliating position than for Labour to provide both government and opposition?
*
Will the possible downfall of Morgan McSweeney mean the return of the Yvette Cooper, so much admired before she took on the mantle of Wicked Witch of the West? Secretary of State for Home Affairs is by tradition one of the three great offices of state, and an appropriate role one would have thought for measured and dignified statements about the state of the nation, of which we know Ms Cooper is capable.
Instead, she screws up her face in that petulant elf look and tries to make it clear she takes the arrival of every refugee and immigrant who manages to reach these shores as a personal affront. So would the defenestration of Morgan McSweeney perhaps mean she can at last begin to acknowledge them at least as fellow human beings?
*
This week saw publication of the regular British social attitudes survey, which confirmed what has been spelt out increasingly over recent years, that old ideas of right and left are now almost redundant; and the most pressing divides are between social liberals and conservatives, libertarians and authoritarians. And those attitudes are defined by age and education.
Yet neither Labour or Tories show any indication of having absorbed or understood these changes. Their strategies are still tied closely to old ideas of right and left; and age-wise they are both aiming at the elderly. (Though quite how Labour’s intended cut in disability benefits squares with that focus is another matter.)
My dears, the two main parties – we might almost say three, given Reform’s aspirations – are all aiming at the same small and diminishing cadre of elderly voters, who don’t understand how the world has turned against them. Those who know how the world works and want to make it work better are meanwhile ignored.
*
When Keir Starmer declares that we should be prepared to confront the danger of war at home, it probably strikes a grim chord. Hence there may well be less protest against an increase in defence spending generally and in particular on tactical nuclear weapons on British soil, especially as long as they are ours. That inevitably involves air bases in East Anglia, and in this case RAF Marham in Norfolk.

The news will no doubt cheer Nick Timothy (W Suffolk), who seems a man who is appreciative of his own qualities, or would be if he could find any. He looks like a Conservative statesman of yore, and shares many of the same ideals of Britain’s place in the world.
So when the government claims their plans represent the biggest strengthening of our defence in a generation, Mr Timothy loves the idea. Only he can’t say so, since it comes from a Labour government. We are told the new F-35A jets will be here before the end of the decade; but Mr Timothy wanted more than that. Like exactly when. “Questions do remain!” quoth Mr Timothy. Only he can’t think of any.
It is hardly the most damning confrontation with government policy. Shadow defence secretary James Cartlidge (S Suffolk) also rushed to ask an urgent question in the House, but then that’s his job and he’s expected to have something to say. Only he was stumped too. He asked the same question, but perhaps Mr Timothy got to the press first. In any case, he will be delighted at having got himself an early headline on this.
*
Nigel Farage (Clacton) has decided it’s time Reform set out some policies, to head off the chi-iking from their political opponents. One fundamental problem they encounter here, though, is they don’t have anybody who knows what they are doing. (This week a Reform council leader somewhere in the Midlands quit the job after just a few weeks, leaving in charge his 18 year-old deputy.)
Hence their big idea: the so-called ‘Britannia card’ – it would be Britannia, wouldn’t it – to attract back non-doms. The money raised by flogging the card is to be paid directly into the bank accounts of the poor.

For a man so avowedly intent on bringing back honour and hard work to the country, it may be indicative that the first idea to appeal to Mr Farage, is to make a sleazy deal for wealthy tax dodgers who will sit on their posteriors and watch under-paid British workers slave to keep them.
This is not quite the phraseology that the Daily Telegraph chose to describe the idea this week, though they did call it “fantasy economics”. Despite this, they still cling to the basic principle that the departure of non-doms from the UK has cost us billions, whereas the research shows it just hasn’t happened. Moreover, data from the Office for Budget Responsibility shows the scheme would actually cost Britain £34 billion over five years.
But the Telegraph prefers to cling to what, in their delusions, should have happened. They do make one good point, though. The money harvested is supposed to go directly into the bank accounts of the deserving, (even though many of the most deserving don’t have bank accounts).
“How the heck is HMRC meant to make regular payments to the lowest 10% of earners? This is an organisation that can hardly answer the phone anymore.”
*
Nigel Farage declared, when he was elected as MP for Clacton, that he would be the town’s “champion”. Since then it’s not clear whether he has even visited the town, and he certainly doesn’t hold local surgeries. Nor does he show up much to promote the town’s interests in the House of Commons.
Then this week, in a survey of 4,000 members by Which, Clacton was voted one of Britain’s worst seaside towns.
*
Thanks to Liz Crosbie (in spite of her brain fog), Karl Whiteman and Malcolm Lynn.
<<< Previous Pecksniff’s Diary











