Watching Clive Lewis sip home-brewed coffee from a red-lidded jam jar on a quiet Norwich street corner, it is easy to see why rumours sometimes gather around him.
The Norwich South MP is one of Labour’s most outspoken critics of Sir Keir Starmer. He regularly works alongside politicians from outside his party and has never hidden his frustration with Labour’s direction under its current leadership.
In recent weeks, that has fuelled two separate stories. One suggested Lewis was considering defecting to the Green Party. Another claimed he would be willing to give up his constituency to create a route back to Westminster for Andy Burnham.
Lewis rejects both ideas. “No, no, no,” he says when asked whether he has considered joining the Greens.
Yet the rumours themselves reveal something interesting about Lewis’s place in British politics. While some on Labour’s left have concluded the party is beyond saving, Lewis remains committed to changing it from within.
Why the Green rumours persist
The speculation is not entirely surprising.
Lewis has spent much of his parliamentary career refusing to engage in the kind of anti-Green rhetoric sometimes heard from Labour politicians.

He points to his long working relationship with former Green leader Caroline Lucas and says colleagues have occasionally questioned where his loyalties lie. “I’ve always had a political culture which understands that progressives, whether they’re in the Labour Party, the trade union movement or the Green Party, have a common agenda,” he says.
For Lewis, that shared agenda centres on confronting what he describes as the hard right. “People mistake that for some kind of weakness. Like I’m going to shift over.”
Those comments carry particular resonance in Norwich, where Labour and the Greens have spent years competing for many of the same voters.
The Greens’ capture of Norwich City Council in the local elections last month ended more than two decades of Labour control and reinforced the party’s growing presence in the city. Yet Norwich politics has never fitted neatly into Westminster assumptions.

Lewis himself served as a Norwich city councillor before entering Parliament in 2015. Throughout that time he has tended to see the Greens less as political enemies and more as rivals with whom Labour shares significant areas of common ground.
That approach increasingly stands out in an era of sharper political division.
More than a Labour-versus-Green contest
The Greens’ local success has inevitably prompted questions about whether Norwich South could become one of the party’s next Westminster targets. But the political picture is more complicated than a simple Labour-versus-Green contest.
Lewis remains one of Norwich’s most recognisable politicians and has often taken positions that resonate with voters beyond Labour’s traditional base. On issues ranging from climate policy to civil liberties and democratic reform, he has frequently found himself closer to Green supporters than many MPs on Labour’s front bench.
That creates an unusual dynamic. Some voters who are comfortable backing the Greens in local elections may also be willing to support Lewis at a general election.
The constituency therefore raises a broader question about the future of progressive politics. Can Labour continue to hold together voters who increasingly have alternatives to their left, or will those voters gradually drift elsewhere?
Lewis’s answer appears to be neither surrender nor defection, but persuasion.

The Burnham question
The second rumour centred on Andy Burnham.
Speculation followed comments Lewis made during a BBC interview last year when he was asked whether he would consider standing aside for Burnham if it were in the national interest. The remarks were widely interpreted as an offer to hand over Norwich South.
Lewis says that interpretation missed the point.
Burnham has since secured a route back to Westminster through Makerfield, making the discussion largely academic. But Lewis remains clear that a parliamentary seat does not belong to the MP who holds it.
“This is my home,” he says. “It’s not my seat to give up. A seat isn’t an MP’s to trade.”
He says the discussion never moved beyond a hypothetical conversation and recalls jokingly telling Burnham: “You’re not having my seat.”
Yet the episode also highlighted Lewis’s belief that Labour needs a different direction.
While he rejects the idea of leaving the party, he has consistently supported figures he believes could broaden Labour’s appeal and reconnect it with voters who feel increasingly alienated.
Labour’s future
Behind both rumours lies a more fundamental disagreement about Labour’s future.
Lewis was among the first Labour MPs to publicly call for Starmer to step aside and he has not softened that position.

“I’ve been one of the key people to say that Keir Starmer and his government, which isn’t fit for purpose, has to go,” he says. “I accept that people are angry with the Labour Party. But I’m angry with it too. I’m trying to change that.”
His criticism goes further still. “Keir Starmer is not fit to be the leader of the Labour Party and he does need to depart. I don’t think he can change the party in the way that it needs to.”
For Lewis, the danger is not simply electoral defeat but a longer-term rupture between Labour and the voters it was created to represent. “It would be deeply problematic if he stayed post the next election,” he says. “I think it would lead to the fundamental break of the Labour Party.”
The rumours about Green defections and constituency swaps may have generated headlines, but Lewis’s response to both points in the same direction.
Despite his frustration with Labour’s leadership and his willingness to work with politicians outside the party, he has not given up on Labour itself. The question for Lewis is not whether Labour should be replaced, but whether it can be persuaded to change course – perhaps under different leadership – before voters decide to replace it themselves.
This article is based on a piece by the Local Democracy Reporting Service, with assistance from AI tools and edited by East Anglia Bylines.
More from East Anglia Bylines

Bylines Network Gazette is out!
The latest Bylines Network Gazette is out now. Become a Friend of Bylines Network or upgrade to a paid Substack subscription, and you will get access to a vital collection of citizen articles and stories.
Journalism by the people, for the people.










