In a previous life, this writer worked on many cases of child sex abuse. The task was to be a media minder for the ‘survivors’ when they brought their accusations to court. (They should never be called ‘victims’. They hate it.) The role was to provide muscle, with the help of Section 10 of the Sexual Offences Act, which forbids breaking a plaintiff’s anonymity, when the case was in public view. The story would be respectfully told, free of the lurid ad hocs to which the hacks might stoop, intentionally or through ignorance.
Lifelong scars
The cases were all historic, involving events which occurred many years ago in childhood, and left the survivors almost invariably mortally scarred for life. Almost every one suffered alcoholism, drug abuse, broken relationships, or inability to hold down a job, their lives ruined. Almost none escaped. And the cause in almost every one was guilt. They had been taught by their abusers that what took place, however disgusting, was of their instigation.
Some had been abused by individuals, but many survivors had suffered at the hands of conspirators – gangs if you like, though ‘gangs’ perhaps deliberately in the present context gives the wrong impression. It sounds – and is no doubt intentionally intended to sound – working class, the acts of seedy groups hanging about rundown council estates.
Whereas the predators in child sex abuse fit no criminal profile. The abuse is almost more likely to be committed by the respectable middle classes as by shady groups in working class towns in the north. But that doesn’t suit those presently perpetrating the lie for their own cynical and nefarious purposes. When Kemi Badenoch writes of “the torture and rape of countless vulnerable, white working-class girls”, we can be in no doubt that she is using the pain and despair of those girls to further her own agenda. Organisations representing the girls have made much the same point.
I have worked on cases involving clergy, teachers, monastic orders, senior police officers, politicians and others. I have never worked on abuse by British-Pakistanis. This does not mean that none are ever involved in child abuse, nor that everyone in those professions is guilty. It means that child sex abuse can take place at every level of society, and to pretend that one group or one race is responsible is grotesque dishonesty.
The bishop and the young girl
Many of the cases on which I worked involved the church, and that invariably meant dealing with a particular high-handed and cynical dishonesty from the church authorities, and often from those supporting the accused. One civil action in particular was about a bishop, who was accused of offences against a young girl many years beforehand. To his supporters he was a near saintly figure, potentially a future Archbishop of Canterbury. They fought his case ruthlessly, but they were mostly members of the House of Lords, high court judges, MPs and other senior clergy. So they had their own means. They lobbied, of course, for one of their own, and in their own way. They knew people. Probably none of those in Oldham – the accused or the girls – knew anybody much beyond their own street. One of the bishop’s supporters in particular was a prominent MP. A school in the errant bishop’s diocese bore his name, but the MP leant on them to change it back. The local newspaper had carried the story throughout and carried its own investigations. The MP called the editor and had the reporter removed from the story. (He left shortly afterwards and now works in East Anglia.)
The supporters’ website carried claims which seemed clearly in breach of the Sexual Offences Act, in that it came close to revealing the claimant’s identity. The police agreed when it was brought to their attention, mentioning the MP. “Right,” said the inspector with relish. “We’ll knock loudly on that gentleman’s door tomorrow.”
After several days without news, the police admitted squeamishly that, after discussions with that gentleman, they had been persuaded they were probably in error, and there had been no breach…
Meanwhile a prominent Sunday newspaper columnist was bullying everyone he could reach. The local BBC studios lived in fear of his next call: how dare they impugn the reputation of such a fine upstanding citizen? (The columnist was polite, but ultimately not very bright. For weeks afterwards he pursued this writer, but the only evidence he could produce was that the bishop was too well respected to have been guilty.)
For the record, the case was won against the bishop (then deceased) and the church.
Jersey, a long way from Oldham
Another case is well known. The systematic abuse and possibly murder at the former Haut de la Garenne children’s home in Jersey. The tales here were lurid, involving sumptuous hotels and penthouses and luxury yachts out there in the bay. The Jersey authorities were furious at the threat to their international reputation as a tax haven. They and their tax-avoiding residents eschewed publicity of any kind, and here they were splashed across the world’s front pages. They forced out the police officer leading the investigation and made cases originating there almost impossible to pursue through the courts. To the knowledge of this writer, no investigation has ever been held, even though there were claims of human remains having been found in the grounds.
All of which is a long way from Oldham and the predominantly British-Pakistani men accused by Kemi Badenoch, Robert Jenrick of others of this type of crime. The rape committed by those among the establishment is of no interest to them: only that which takes place against white girls and by Asian men. The dog whistle is deafening.
Of no interest to the Conservative and Reform MPs
Conspiracies of sexual abusers certainly exist, still. But where they involve those other than Pakistanis – those perhaps in higher social echelons, even perhaps those who contribute to political parties – they seem unlikely to prove of interest to the Conservative and Reform MPs who have been so vociferous in their dog whistling this week.
Child sex abuse is not a crime restricted to the working classes, let alone Pakistanis. It occurs across society. We might just as easily and as accurately claim it is a tax dodgers’ crime.
Share this article on Bluesky








