Conservative party leader Kemi Badenoch, when she was secretary of state for business and trade, gave a nearly £10m contract extension to a council service already mired in financial difficulties.
Badenoch, the MP for North West Essex, became the leader of the Conservative and Unionist party on Saturday 2 November 2024 and will end 2024 as the sixth leader of the party in less than nine years.
Despite her recent success, eyebrows have now been raised at her actions in the role she had at the start of 2024.
The ‘wrong arm’ of the law?
When she was secretary of state for business and trade, her department oversaw the awarding of a £9.9m contract extension to Thurrock Council for use of the services of their controversial NATIS fraud investigation team, who have been accused of acting like police officers without the legal authority to do so.

The extension was revealed by the online investigative journalist Mrbounceback.com. The contract extension began on 1 April 2024 and is to last for one year.
The Times reported that the original contract between the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) and Thurrock, valued at £30m, was signed in 2020 just months after the Financial Times and the Bureau of Investigative Journalism both reported on Thurrock Council’s high-risk investments in solar farms.
Those investments led to Thurrock effectively declaring bankruptcy in 2022, after it had borrowed £1.5bn. The council was found to be ‘unconsciously incompetent’ when inspected by Essex County Council in 2023. The ECC report was handed to the government and accepted by ministers. Speaking at the time, Lee Rowley, the under-secretary of state for levelling up, housing, and communities, said: “The report concludes that these failings are attributable to the breakdown of political and managerial leadership; inadequate governance arrangements; and profound weaknesses in the council’s control environment.”
Good money after bad?
When the £9.9m contract extension was signed less than a year later, Thurrock was already known to be effectively bankrupt, and shortly before it was exposed that NATIS was misrepresenting itself as a police organisation.
The Times report had revealed that the agreement between BEIS and Thurrock meant council staff were not simply working with the government department, but were directly seconded to it, thus implicating BEIS in the growing controversy around NATIS. And an independent report produced by auditors Mazars in March this year revealed that neither ministers nor council managers had any oversight of the contract.
When a Freedom of Information Act request was made by East Anglia Bylines, the Department for Business and Trade advised that it did not have exact records for how NATIS was hired by them in the first place.
The ministerial code
Section 1.6(b) of the ministerial code states that Ministers “have a duty to Parliament to account, and be held to account, for the policies, decisions and actions of their departments and agencies.”
In her victory speech Badenoch said: “The party must admit it ‘made mistakes’ and had ‘let standards slip’ over the last 14 years in government.”
Badenoch need perhaps not be troubled by every decision taken by the Conservatives in government. However, the decision by her own department to spend £9.9m to extend a contract to a body that was apparently not fit to fulfill it is a cause for concern. And when staff from a council in Essex were allowed to continue to present themselves as police officers on the internet, this was clearly a failure of governance and oversight.
Time will tell if she shows any acknowledgement of her own part in the Conservatives’ mistakes and slipped standards.












