The New Year has brought no joy to the beleaguered Unitary Authority of Thurrock, situated on the south Essex Coast.
The Conservative run council has been effectively bankrupt since December when it was forced to issue a Section 114 Notice. As previously reported, this limits the council to spending only on ‘statutory obligations’ with cuts needed to be found elsewhere to address the near half a billion pound black hole in its budget.
As a result, on 5 January 2023, Thurrock Council proposed the following savings. These include: no vacant posts in the Housing Revenue Account Team will be filled, and social tenancies’ rents will be increased by 7%. There will also be increases in ground rent, garage rents and fees for traveller sites. The proposals were set out in the report to the Housing Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Whilst this is the first budget report submitted since the S114 notice, it will not be the last. More savings will be sought in non-statutory areas and it is inevitable that costs will rise.
Some good news
The council did manage to give a small bit of good news for some. It’s proposing that it retains its own council tax support scheme mostly because it is less expensive than the central government alternative. The scheme is open to certain benefits claimants and covers up to 75% of a household’s council tax. The most recent figures from October 2022 show the number of claimants was just over 9000.
At an Extraordinary General Meeting held on Monday 9 January, Thurrock Council’s opposition leader Cllr John Kent delivered a scathing condemnation of the Conservative administration’s performance since it took control in 2016. After describing all the events that led up to the current crisis, he said, “We are being asked this evening to agree to raise Council Tax by more that the 5% referendum limit, without holding that local referendum. I want to be very clear, the Labour Group will not be supporting that recommendation. The residents of Thurrock were not responsible for this disaster. They will already be paying more for less, and we have a responsibility to do what we can to protect residents, especially in this cost-of-living crisis.”

An appetite for risk
The revelations that led to the current crisis appeared only recently in the news but it is clear that concerns were raised about the council’s handling of its finances back in 2018. Financial advisors, Arlingclose, wrote to the Director of Finance and Resources personally to warn of the councils ‘extreme’ appetite for risk in terms of investments, which were ‘well beyond’ those of its other clients. As such, there are questions that need to be addressed.
From November 2016 to October 2019, covering the period of the investments to the solar farms that triggered the crisis, through to the abrupt ending of the partnership, Thurrock Council had a partnership with Southend on Sea City Council to investigate fraud.
The Counter Fraud & Investigation Directorate (CFID) was established by Southend and Thurrock in such a way to allow investigators from Southend to monitor Thurrock and vice versa. To provide oversight and governance, they had senior executives from Thurrock, Southend-on-Sea, and , Castle Point Councils as well as from South Essex Homes (Southend’s Arm’s Length Management Organisation (ALMO)) to monitor it via a joint Services Board. The CFID was based or ‘hosted’ in Thurrock and an assistant director from that council was employed to head of the directorate.
Counter fraud and investigation department asleep at the wheel
It is ironic that officers from the CFID have, in other cases, shown no fear in pursuing allegations and have even launched detailed investigations into councillors, and used Counter Terrorist legislation to aid their efforts. Yet they failed to monitor the council’s investments, the sheer scale of which should have rung alarm bells.
Across a three year period, at a time when financial advisors raised concerns, when there were anecdotal jokes about the ‘boss’ going off to ‘gamble with all the money,’ Freedom of Information Act requests were submitted by journalists, the fraud team was physically based at Thurrock Council. The CFID was also able to use electronic surveillance and legally follow and monitor individuals.
With all of these warning signals, all of these powers, two questions remains unanswered. Why did the staff of the finance team in Thurrock, the members of staff of the CFID, the senior executives in Thurrock Council, Castle Point Council, Southend on Sea City Council, and, South Essex Homes, not raise the concerns with the assistant director and head of the CFID, David Kleinberg? Also why, in turn, did he not gain authorisation from any of those aforementioned executives to investigate the director of Finance for Thurrock, Sean Clark?







