Thurrock Council has commenced legal action against 23 councils to recover approximately £40m. These local authorities are members of the Association for Public Service Excellence (APSE), the industry body that Thurrock Council claims assured the valuation of an investment in companies under the Rockfire Energy banner. Thurrock says that the valuation was “negligent” and the assets overvalued.
What is APSE?
APSE is an organisation that connects councils and public service teams across the country, helping them share expertise, ideas and best practice to improve frontline services. It has over 300 member authorities, providing practical support, fostering collaboration and working to strengthen public services that directly impact local communities. The organisation is set up as an unincorporated association, like a sports club or other voluntary group, which operates as a not-for-profit entity. Unlike a limited company, the individual members of an unincorporated association are “personally responsible for any debts and contractual obligations.” This last part is critical for Thurrock’s legal case.
The Bureau of Investigative Journalism identified two councils Thurrock is pursuing in our region as Hertfordshire County Council and Luton Borough council, as well as Gedling, Derby, Bolsover, Wolverhampton, South Tyneside, Warrington, Stockton-on-Tees, Preston, West Lindsey, East Riding of Yorkshire, Isle of Wight, Eastleigh, South Oxfordshire, Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole, Oxfordshire, Bristol, Swansea, Vale of Glamorgan, Cardiff, Southampton and Flintshire.
A brief reminder of the background
Between 2017-20, as reported in a number of East Anglia Bylines articles, the then Conservative-led Thurrock Council made a number of questionable investments in a solar energy project that led to huge losses. The council subsequently sought to recover as much money as possible, with council tax rises of 9.99%, as well as legal action against Liam Kavanagh, the businessman behind Rockfire Energy.
In December 2022, the Council was effectively declared bankrupt after having borrowed £1.5bn to hide the losses from its failed investments. The scandal led to the resignations of the Chief Executive and the Director for Finance, Legal and IT in late 2022 and early 2023 respectively. A report produced by Essex County Council in 2023 described the management of Thurrock Council as ‘unconsciously incompetent’.
Why the action against APSE?

The incoming Labour-led council is, unsurprisingly, determined to recover as much of the losses as possible. Due to legal time limits on bringing the case to court, Thurrock argued that it had no choice but to start the proceedings against the other councils now. Thurrock has also sought permission for this legal action against APSE members to be suspended in order to give it time to pursue their ongoing claim against Liam Kavanagh first.
Cllr John Kent, Leader of Thurrock Council, said:
“We know what a challenging time this is for all councils, and we never wanted to pursue individual councils, but unfortunately, APSE didn’t have adequate insurance or protection in place, meaning that its member councils are liable for consequences of decisions taken by APSE.”
On 18 November, following commencement of legal action, APSE issued a press release re-iterating their disappointment in Thurrock taking legal action. APSE reaffirm their intention to support the member councils involved and highlight the criticism levelled at Thurrock in the ‘Best Value Report‘ published in 2023.
APSE stated:
“It is…a remarkably audacious choice for Thurrock’s current leadership – which includes the same appointed commissioners who recognised such weaknesses in governance, control, and political leadership in the council – to have turned their attention not to where the real fault lies, but to seek instead to recover from other local authorities who are not to blame for Thurrock’s losses.
“APSE will assist in defending its members from this egregious attack.”
What now?
While the financial situation facing Thurrock is dire due to past mismanagement, the current situation would only transfer those issues to other councils. The money recovered will not make Thurrock whole again, but it could well force other authorities to fail.
The additional concern is that while Thurrock is bringing legal proceedings against 23 councils which are APSE members, the actual membership comprises over 300 local authorities.
Speaking prior to the legal action commencing, the APSE chief Executive, Mo Burnes, told the Local Government Chronicle that while Thurrock had selected 23 APSE members to write to, it is a “fool’s errand to believe that this could just be something that’s contained to a small cohort.” She said that, “this is a very dark day” for councils, and fears that “the contagion will spread across local government.” She added that she intends to write to the finance ministers in the Scottish Parliament, the Senedd and the Northern Ireland Assembly about the issue.
The BBC reported that a spokesperson for South Tyneside Council considers the legal action against it to be “completely unjustified”, and Stockton Borough Council is “considering our next steps”.
It is clear that the fallout of this case, for local authorities and the bodies that they form part of, will be discussed, and need to be dealt with, for years to come.











